Industrial raw materials are not consumer goods: confiscation, redemption fine and penalty were set aside for shoe-upper material.

Imported nylon-foam-tricot composite material used for manufacturing shoe uppers was treated as industrial raw material rather than consumer goods, because the record showed its intended manufacturing use. On that basis, the Tribunal stated that confiscation on the footing of consumer-goods classification was not sustainable. It also noted that prior treatment of similar goods supported that view, and that later re-export of the consignments further weakened the basis for redemption fine and penalty. The result stated in the text was that confiscation, redemption fine and penalty were set aside, with consequential relief to the importer.

---

---

Issues: Whether imported footwear material, described as a nylon-foam-tricot composite, was correctly treated as consumer goods liable to confiscation and penalty, and whether redemption fine and penalty could be sustained when the goods were intended as industrial raw materials and were later re-exported.

Analysis: The adjudication record itself showed that the goods were meant for use in manufacturing shoe uppers, which made them industrial raw materials rather than goods meant for public consumption. On that footing, they could not be classified as consumer goods for the purpose of confiscation. The Tribunal also noted that similar goods had earlier been held not to be consumer goods, and that the subsequent re-export of the consignments further weakened the basis for imposing redemption fine and penalty.

Conclusion: The confiscation and penalty were not justified, and the redemption fine and penalty were set aside.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded, with consequential relief to the importer.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods shown to be industrial raw materials intended for manufacture are not consumer goods merely because they are imported as composite material, and confiscation or penalty based on contrary classification cannot be sustained.

---