Taxpayer fails to prove employee occupation of flat, business expenses partially allowed with 20% disallowance

ITAT Mumbai-AT decided an appeal involving multiple issues regarding house property income and business expenses. For interest on loans for Surat property purchase, the matter was remanded to AO for fresh adjudication due to insufficient evidence initially provided. Regarding deemed rent on Borivali flat allegedly occupied by employees, the addition was confirmed as assessee failed to prove employee occupation with supporting evidence. Business expenses disallowance was partially allowed, with AO's action restricted to 20% disallowance considering possible personal use of telephone, mobile, and conveyance expenses. Interest on unsecured loans was disallowed as assessee couldn't establish nexus between borrowing and income generation from amenity charges and FD interest. Assessee's consistency argument based on earlier years' acceptance was rejected due to lack of evidence showing proper scrutiny in previous assessments.

---

---

Issues Involved:

1. Addition of Rs. 4,71,939/- on account of interest paid on loans for Surat Property.
2. Addition of Rs. 1,68,000/- on account of deemed rent of Borivali flat.
3. Addition of Rs. 1,65,016/- on account of business expenses treated as personal expenses.
4. Addition of Rs. 3,82,476/- on account of disallowing interest paid on unsecured loan against bank interest and amenity charges.
5. Addition of Rs. 3,82,476/- on account of disallowing interest paid on unsecured loan against interest received on loans and advances.

Summary:

Issue 1: Addition of Rs. 4,71,939/- on account of interest paid on loans for Surat Property:

The assessee claimed a deduction of Rs. 4,71,939/- as interest paid on loans borrowed for the purchase of a Surat property given on rent. The AO disallowed this claim due to the non-production of an interest certificate as required by the third proviso to section 24(b) of the Income Tax Act. The Tribunal found merit in the assessee's argument that the third proviso was not applicable since the property was rented out and not covered under section 23(2). However, the issue was remanded back to the AO for fresh adjudication to verify the use of borrowed capital for the property.

Issue 2: Addition of Rs. 1,68,000/- on account of deemed rent of Borivali flat:

The AO added Rs. 1,68,000/- as deemed rent for the Borivali flat, which the assessee claimed was occupied by employees. The assessee failed to provide evidence supporting this claim. The Tribunal upheld the AO's decision, noting the absence of proof that the flat was used by employees and the lack of perquisite expenses in the Profit and Loss account.

Issue 3: Addition of Rs. 1,65,016/- on account of business expenses treated as personal expenses:

The AO disallowed Rs. 1,65,016/- out of the total business expenses claimed, citing that the expenses were not incurred wholly and exclusively for business purposes, given that the assessee only conducted one bullion transaction in the year. The Tribunal partially upheld this disallowance, restricting it to 20% of the claimed expenses due to the potential personal element in the expenditures.

Issue 4 & 5: Addition of Rs. 3,82,476/- on account of disallowing interest paid on unsecured loan:

The AO disallowed Rs. 3,82,476/- claimed under section 57(iii) of the Act, stating that the assessee failed to establish a direct nexus between the borrowed funds and the income generated from amenities and fixed deposit interest. The assessee's argument for consistency based on previous years' assessments was rejected, as those assessments were not scrutinized for the deduction under section 57(iii). The Tribunal upheld the disallowance due to the lack of evidence proving the nexus between the borrowed funds and the income.

Conclusion:

The appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes, with specific issues remanded back to the AO for fresh adjudication and others upheld due to lack of substantiating evidence.

Order pronounced in the open court on this 01/09/2023.

---