Customs penalty reduced and fine maintained in appeal; Tribunal cites inaccurate profit margin assessment.

The Tribunal modified the Order-in-Original by reducing the penalty imposed under Section 112(a) of the Customs Act, 1962, from Rs. 3,10,000/- to Rs. 48,000/-, while maintaining the redemption fine of Rs. 1,91,000/-. The appellant's appeal was partially allowed, with the Tribunal acknowledging the failure of the original authority to consider the profit margin accurately. The decision was rendered by Hon'ble Mr. Anil G. Shakkarwar, Member (Technical) of the Appellate Tribunal CESTAT Mumbai on 11.05.2023.

---

---

Issues:
The case involves the valuation of imported rough marble slabs, imposition of redemption fine and penalty under Section 112(a) of the Customs Act, 1962, and the failure of the original authority to consider the appellant's submissions regarding profit margin.

Valuation of Imported Marble Slabs:
The appellant imported rough marble slabs with a declared value of US $310 (CIF) per metric ton, below the required US $450 for import without a Special Import License. The original authority enhanced the value to US $450 per metric ton for assessment, which the appellant agreed to. The goods were confiscated, and a redemption fine of Rs. 1,91,000/- was imposed along with a penalty of Rs. 48,000/-. The Tribunal remanded the matter multiple times for fresh adjudication to determine the profit margin accurately.

Failure to Consider Profit Margin:
The appellant argued that despite showing a loss of Rs. 73,298/- in the calculation sheet submitted to the original authority, the redemption fine and penalty remained unchanged. The appellant contended that the original authority did not comply with the Tribunal's direction to verify the profit margin, rendering the order invalid.

Tribunal's Decision:
After reviewing the case records and submissions, the Tribunal found that the original authority did not consider the appellant's detailed calculations and written submissions. The Tribunal acknowledged the appellant's argument that the penalty should be restricted to 5% of the assessable value and reduced the penalty from Rs. 3,10,000/- to Rs. 48,000/- under Section 112(a) of the Customs Act, 1962. The redemption fine of Rs. 1,91,000/- remained unchanged as it had already been paid by the appellant during goods clearance.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal modified the impugned Order-in-Original by reducing the penalty while maintaining the redemption fine, partially allowing the appeal. The decision was pronounced in open court on 11.05.2023 by Hon'ble Mr. Anil G. Shakkarwar, Member (Technical) of the Appellate Tribunal CESTAT Mumbai.

---