GST Liability on Leasing Tank Containers from Foreign Supplier: Lease Transaction as Taxable Supply

The case involved determining the GST liability on leasing tank containers from a foreign supplier when the containers do not enter India and whether the lease transaction amounts to a taxable supply under GST law. The authority found that the transaction did not meet the conditions of a sale under the CGST Act, as the lessee had an option to purchase the containers at the end of the lease term, making it a service until the purchase option was exercised. The ruling concluded that the applicant is liable to pay IGST on the importation of lease services into India.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Whether GST is liable to be paid on leasing of tank containers from a supplier located outside India when the containers do not reach India.
2. Whether the hire-purchase/lease transaction amounts to a taxable supply under GST law.

Detailed Analysis:

Issue 1: GST Liability on Leasing of Tank Containers from a Foreign Supplier

The applicant, M/s. Deccan Transco Leasing Private Limited (DTLPL), entered into a lease purchase agreement with M/s. Tankspan Leasing Limited (TLL) for leasing tank containers. The applicant argued that this transaction should be considered a supply of goods under Entry 1(c) of Schedule II to Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017, as the containers are recognized as assets in their books from the lease inception, with a certainty of purchase later.

The applicant contended that the transaction is a deemed sale of goods, referring to Entry 29A of Article 366 of the Constitution of India and various case laws. They argued that since the goods never entered the Indian territory, the transaction should not attract GST under CGST/IGST Acts, relying on the case of Mohit Minerals Vs UOI (2020) 33 GSTL 321 (GUJ).

Discussion and Findings:

The authority examined the lease agreement and found that the transaction does not meet the conditions of Entry 1(c) of Schedule II to the CGST Act, 2017. The agreement provided an option for the lessee to purchase the containers at the end of the lease period, rather than an obligation. Key points from the agreement included:

- The agreement is titled as a "Lease Purchase Agreement."
- The lessee pays a daily rate for the lease and has an option to purchase the containers at the end of the lease term.
- There is no binding obligation for the purchase of goods; the lessee may return the containers to the lessor.
- The ownership of the containers remains with the lessor during the lease term.

The authority concluded that the transaction remains a service during the lease period and only becomes a sale when the option to purchase is exercised. Therefore, the transaction does not fall under Entry 1(c) of Schedule II to the CGST Act.

Issue 2: Taxable Supply Under GST Law

The applicant's argument that the transaction is a supply of goods was rejected. The authority emphasized that the transaction remains a lease service until the option to purchase is exercised. The lease agreement did not stipulate an obligatory transfer of property, which is a requirement under Entry 1(c) of Schedule II.

The authority referred to the case of K.L. Johar & Co. Vs Dy. Commercial Tax Officer, AIR 1965 SC 1083, which distinguished between a hire purchase agreement and a sale where the price is paid in installments. In a hire purchase agreement, the property in goods passes only when the option to purchase is exercised, not when the agreement is made.

Advance Ruling:

Question Raised:
Is GST liable to be paid on leasing of tank containers taken from a supplier located outside India when the containers do not reach IndiaRs.

Advance Ruling Issued:
Yes. The applicant is liable to pay IGST on the importation of lease services into India.

---