Substantive compliance under exemption notification preserved entitlement despite procedural defects in Chapter X requirements.

Exemption Notification No. 154/70 was applied on a substantive compliance basis, with Chapter X procedure treated as satisfied in substance. The classification list dated 3-6-1974 was not disputed, and the authorities did not contest that the goods were used for the purpose relevant to the exemption. The absence of certain formalities and other alleged procedural defects was held insufficient to deny the notification benefit where the essential conditions were otherwise met. Accordingly, procedural objections did not defeat entitlement to the exemption.

---

---

Issues: Whether the petitioners were entitled to the benefit of Exemption Notification No. 154/70 despite alleged non-compliance with certain procedural requirements under Chapter X.

Analysis: The application of Chapter X procedure was found to have been followed in substance. The classification list dated 3-6-1974 was not controverted, and the authorities did not dispute that the goods were used for the purpose relevant to the exemption. The absence of certain formalities, including the complained-of procedural defects, was treated as insufficient to deny the substantive benefit of the notification where the essential requirements were otherwise satisfied.

Conclusion: The petitioners were held entitled to the exemption and the procedural objections did not defeat the claim.

---