Exemption notification nexus test controls eligibility: Radio Modem qualified, while air conditioner and ducting system failed.

Eligibility for exemption under the applicable notifications turns on a demonstrated nexus between the goods and the manufacturing or production process, and exemption provisions are to be strictly construed. Applying that principle, the Radio Modem, used for recording and updating production and operations data through SCADA and SAP applications, was treated as connected with factory activity and eligible for exemption. By contrast, no evidence showed that the conference room where the 3.0 ton air conditioner and ducting system were installed was used for production or operations related to export goods, so the exemption claim failed for those items.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether Radio Modem was eligible for exemption under the applicable notifications; (ii) Whether the 3.0 ton air conditioner and the ducting system were eligible for exemption under the applicable notifications.

Issue (i): Whether Radio Modem was eligible for exemption under the applicable notifications.

Analysis: The Radio Modem was stated to be used for recording and updating production and operations data within the factory through SCADA and SAP applications. On that basis, the goods were found to have a nexus with the manufacturing activity, and it could not be said that there was no connection between the impugned goods and the manufactured products.

Conclusion: Radio Modem was held eligible for exemption and the finding is in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether the 3.0 ton air conditioner and the ducting system were eligible for exemption under the applicable notifications.

Analysis: No evidence was produced to show that the conference room, where the air conditioner and ducting system were installed, was used in connection with production or operations related to the export goods. In the absence of proof of nexus, and applying strict construction to exemption notifications, the claim for exemption failed.

Conclusion: The 3.0 ton air conditioner and the ducting system were held not eligible for exemption and the finding is against the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded only to the extent of the Radio Modem and failed for the air conditioner and ducting system, resulting in a partial allowance of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Eligibility under an exemption notification depends on a proved nexus between the goods and the manufacturing or production process, and exemption provisions must be strictly construed.

---