Tribunal reduces cash expenditure disallowance, deletes unexplained credits, upholds 10% disallowance for justice.

The Tribunal partially allowed the appeal by deleting the addition of unexplained credits totaling Rs. 43,12,250 from four individuals and reducing the disallowance of cash expenditure to Rs. 1,35,468. The Tribunal found that the cash credits were advances for plot bookings later converted into sales revenue, with registered sale deeds confirming the transactions. Despite genuine expenditures supported by vendor statements and vouchers, a 10% disallowance was deemed appropriate for justice. The decision was rendered on 26.12.2018.

---

---

Issues Involved:

1. Addition of unexplained credits from four individuals.
2. Disallowance of cash expenditure.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Addition of Unexplained Credits from Four Individuals:

The assessee, engaged in the business of construction and colonization, received advances for plot booking from various parties. The Revenue added Rs. 43,12,250/- as unexplained cash credits from four individuals: Shri Ram Kumar Gangrade, Late Vinod Thakkar, Shri Arun Bhatt, and Shri Ravish Patel. The assessee argued that these amounts were received as advances for plot bookings, which were later converted into sales revenue and offered for tax in the relevant assessment years.

The Tribunal examined the records and found that the sale deeds were registered in the names of these individuals, confirming the transactions. The Tribunal noted that the identity of the cash creditors was established, and the genuineness and creditworthiness were verified through registered sale deeds. The Tribunal concluded that there was no loss to the Revenue as the sale consideration was duly offered to tax. Therefore, the addition of Rs. 43,12,250/- as unexplained cash credits was deleted, allowing Grounds No. 1 to 4 of the assessee’s appeal.

2. Disallowance of Cash Expenditure:

The Revenue disallowed Rs. 13,54,680/- out of total expenditures of Rs. 24,43,811/- due to the lack of necessary vouchers and records. The assessee contended that the vouchers were submitted before the first appellate authority, and statements from vendors confirmed the receipt of amounts for services provided.

The Tribunal reviewed the evidence, including statements from vendors and vouchers, and found that the expenditures were genuine. However, to balance the interests of justice, the Tribunal deemed a 10% disallowance of the impugned expenditure justified. Consequently, the disallowance was reduced to Rs. 1,35,468/-, partly allowing Ground No. 5 of the assessee’s appeal.

Conclusion:

The Tribunal partly allowed the appeal, deleting the addition of unexplained credits amounting to Rs. 43,12,250/- and reducing the disallowance of cash expenditure to Rs. 1,35,468/-. The order was pronounced in the open Court on 26.12.2018.

---