Extended limitation for wrongful Cenvat credit applies where suppression and intent to evade duty are specifically alleged.

A show cause notice alleging wrongful availment of Cenvat credit on outward freight beyond the place of removal can support invocation of the extended limitation period under Section 11A where suppression, contravention of the rules, or intent to evade duty is specifically pleaded and established on the record. The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that the assessee's limitation objection failed because the concept of place of removal was already available in the excise framework, and the demand for reversal of credit, interest, and penalty was therefore not time barred.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the demand for reversal of Cenvat credit and consequential recovery, interest, and penalty was barred by limitation, and whether the extended period under Section 11A could be invoked on the facts pleaded.

Analysis: The notice and the adverse orders proceeded on the basis that the assessee had taken Cenvat credit on outward freight beyond the place of removal, contrary to the governing definition of input service and the statutory concept of place of removal under the Central Excise law. The Court noted that Section 11A permits the extended period where non-payment or short payment arises from suppression of facts, contravention of provisions, or intent to evade duty, and that the show cause notice specifically alleged wrongful availment of credit in contravention of the Cenvat Credit Rules with intent to evade payment. On the facts recorded, the assessee's plea that the definition of place of removal was inserted only later was not accepted, because the same concept was already available through the excise law and the rules governing undefined expressions. The Court therefore held that the Revenue had validly invoked the extended limitation period and that the demand was not time barred.

Conclusion: The plea of limitation failed and the invocation of the extended period was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a show cause notice specifically alleges wrongful availment of Cenvat credit in contravention of the rules with intent to evade duty, the extended period under Section 11A is available and the demand is not barred by limitation if the ingredients of suppression or contravention are established on the record.

---