Service Tax Applicability on Anywhere Banking Business Transactions Clarified by Tribunal

The Tribunal upheld the impugned order, ruling that Anywhere Banking Business (ABB) transactions were not liable to service tax before 10.9.2004 but became taxable thereafter due to an amendment in the definition of banking services. The decision was based on the understanding that ABB services enabled customers to operate their accounts from branches other than where the accounts were held, falling within the scope of service tax post the specified date.

---

---

Issues:
Appeal against common impugned order holding Anywhere Banking Business (ABB) transactions not liable to service tax.

Analysis:
The Revenue filed appeals against a common impugned order regarding Anywhere Banking Business (ABB) transactions not being liable to service tax. The Revenue argued that charges collected by the respondents for ABB transactions fall under the scope of banking services as defined under Section 65(12) of the Finance Act, 1994, which includes the provision and transfer of information and data processing. They contended that ABB services provided by the respondents involve transferring information and data through their network, enabling customers to operate their accounts from branches other than where they hold their accounts. The Revenue emphasized that without this data transfer, banks would not be able to access customers' accounts operated from different branches. The Revenue asserted that the impugned order was unsustainable due to these reasons.

The respondents, on the other hand, argued that ABB services became subject to service tax only from 10.9.2004 onwards, and therefore, prior to this date, the service was not chargeable to service tax. The Tribunal examined the nature of ABB services, noting that it allows customers to operate their accounts from branches other than where the accounts are held, facilitating activities like depositing or withdrawing money. The Tribunal observed that the service of operating bank accounts by customers fell within the ambit of service tax starting from 10.9.2004, following an amendment to the definition of banking services. Since the service was specifically for account operation by customers, the Tribunal found no fault in the impugned order and consequently dismissed the appeals.

In conclusion, the Tribunal upheld the impugned order, ruling that ABB transactions were not liable to service tax before 10.9.2004 but became taxable thereafter due to an amendment in the definition of banking services. The decision was based on the understanding that ABB services enabled customers to operate their accounts from branches other than where the accounts were held, falling within the scope of service tax post the specified date.

---