ITAT allows transfer pricing adjustments using CUP method with simple arithmetic mean and grants Section 92C(2) benefit

The ITAT Mumbai ruled on multiple transfer pricing and tax issues for the assessee. For transfer pricing adjustments, the tribunal applied CUP method using simple arithmetic mean of comparable transactions and allowed 40% adjustment on marketing and research costs while granting +/-5% benefit under Section 92C(2). The tribunal allowed depreciation on NSE membership cards at 25%, permitted club membership fees as deductible, and deleted disallowances under Section 40A(2) for remuneration and interest-free deposits. Other allowances included overseas support services, lease rentals, and transaction charges to stock exchanges. The tribunal restricted Section 14A disallowance to Rs.1,00,000 and remanded one 14A issue for re-examination. The weighted average methodology for computing arithmetic mean was rejected in favor of simple average.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Upward adjustment in determining the ALP of international transactions.
2. Application of CUP method and adjustments.
3. Applicability of TNMM.
4. Depreciation on NSE membership card.
5. Disallowance of club membership fees.
6. Disallowance of remuneration paid under Section 40A(2).
7. Disallowance of interest under Section 40A(2)(b).
8. Disallowance of interest on loss on IT&T shares.
9. Transfer pricing adjustment for overseas support services.
10. Disallowance under Section 14A.
11. Disallowance of lease line charges, VSAT charges under Section 40(a)(ia).
12. Short grant of TDS.
13. Assessment of incorrect amount of income under the head profits and gains from business.

Summary:

1. Upward Adjustment in Determining the ALP of International Transactions:
The assessee challenged the upward adjustment of INR 1,50,72,130 for equity broking services to AEs. The Tribunal upheld the application of the CUP method over TNMM for determining the ALP. The Tribunal directed that adjustments should be made for marketing, research costs, and volume discounts, restricting the adjustment to 40%.

2. Application of CUP Method and Adjustments:
The Tribunal affirmed the use of the CUP method and directed that the simple average of brokerage rates should be used instead of the weighted average. Adjustments for marketing costs, research costs, and volume discounts were restricted to 40%.

3. Applicability of TNMM:
The Tribunal dismissed the applicability of TNMM as not pressed by the assessee.

4. Depreciation on NSE Membership Card:
The Tribunal allowed depreciation on NSE membership cards under Section 32(1), following the Supreme Court's decision in Techno Shares and Stocks Ltd.

5. Disallowance of Club Membership Fees:
The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's challenge, allowing the club membership fees as deductible, relying on the Bombay High Court's judgment in Otis Elevator Co. Ltd. vs. CIT.

6. Disallowance of Remuneration Paid Under Section 40A(2):
The Tribunal deleted the disallowance of remuneration paid to Mr. Ashith Kampani, following its earlier decisions in the assessee's own case for previous years.

7. Disallowance of Interest Under Section 40A(2)(b):
The Tribunal deleted the disallowance of notional interest on interest-free security deposits, following the Bombay High Court's decision in Karma Energy.

8. Disallowance of Interest on Loss on IT&T Shares:
The Tribunal upheld the deletion of disallowance of interest on loss on IT&T shares, considering it a business expense.

9. Transfer Pricing Adjustment for Overseas Support Services:
The Tribunal directed the deletion of the transfer pricing adjustment for overseas support services, noting that the assessee had justified the need, rendition, and benefit of the services received.

10. Disallowance Under Section 14A:
The Tribunal remanded the issue back to the AO to examine the disallowance under Section 14A, directing the assessee to substantiate its claim.

11. Disallowance of Lease Line Charges, VSAT Charges Under Section 40(a)(ia):
The Tribunal deleted the disallowance of lease line charges, VSAT charges, and transaction charges, following the Supreme Court's decision in CIT vs. Kotak Securities Ltd.

12. Short Grant of TDS:
The Tribunal remanded the issue of short grant of TDS back to the AO for examination and consequential relief.

13. Assessment of Incorrect Amount of Income Under the Head Profits and Gains from Business:
The Tribunal directed the AO to examine and rectify the assessment of the incorrect amount of income under the head profits and gains from business.

Conclusion:
The appeals and cross objections of the assessee were partly allowed, and the appeals of the Revenue were dismissed. The Tribunal provided detailed directions for each issue, ensuring consistency with previous decisions and judicial precedents.

---