Specific exclusion governs tax classification of deep freezers; residuary entry applied despite broad description.

Deep freezers were held to be distinct from refrigerators and air conditioners in design, utility, temperature range and power requirements, so they could not be classified under that specific entry. The later notification expressly excluded deep freezers from the air conditioner and refrigerator entry, and earlier notifications had treated them separately, supporting residuary classification. The HSN-based argument was not accepted because it was not part of the original proceedings and could not override the specific exclusion in the applicable notification. The principles of specific entry preference and the revenue's burden to establish coverage were applied, with the result that deep freezers were rightly placed in the residuary entry in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether deep freezers fall within the specific entry for air conditioners and refrigerators or under the residuary entry for the purpose of tax classification.

Analysis: The competing entries were examined with reference to the nature, construction, utility and end use of deep freezers. The goods were found to be distinct from refrigerators and air conditioners in design, temperature range, power requirements and commercial utility. The later notification specifically excluded deep freezers from the entry for air conditioners and refrigerators, while earlier notifications had shown them separately, indicating that the legislature treated them as a distinct product. The HSN-based contention was not accepted because it had not formed part of the original proceedings and, in any event, could not override the specific exclusion in the applicable notification. The principles relating to preference for a specific entry and the burden on the revenue to establish coverage were applied.

Conclusion: Deep freezers do not fall within the specific entry for air conditioners and refrigerators and were rightly treated under the residuary entry. The finding is in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing notification specifically excludes a commodity from a particular entry, the commodity cannot be classified within that entry merely on a broad or generic description, and the revenue must establish clear coverage before displacing the residuary classification.

---