Dredger classification turns on substantive vessel character, not machinery, defeating entry tax treatment under the Karnataka entry tax law.

A registered dredger used as a self-propelled sea-going craft was classified according to its substantive character as a ship or vessel, not as machinery under Entry 52 of the First Schedule to the Karnataka Tax on Entry of Goods Act, 1979. The HC relied on the Merchant Shipping Act definitions, the dredger's registration as an Indian ship, and common parlance usage to conclude that it functioned as an ocean-going vessel used for dredging and de-silting rather than machinery simpliciter. The levy of entry tax on the basis that it was machinery was therefore not sustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether dredgers are classifiable as machinery under Entry 52 of the First Schedule to the Karnataka Tax on Entry of Goods Act, 1979 or are ocean-going vessels ships and therefore outside that entry.

Analysis: Dredgers were treated as registered Indian ships under the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, and the statutory definitions of ship and Indian ship, together with their registration status and functional character, were examined. The Court also relied on the common parlance meaning of dredgers and their treatment in other fiscal and shipping contexts, noting that they operate as self-propelled sea-going craft used for dredging and de-silting rather than as machinery simpliciter. On that basis, the character of the dredger was held to be that of a vessel or ship and not machinery within Entry 52.

Conclusion: Dredgers are ocean-going vessels ships and not machinery for the purposes of the Karnataka Tax on Entry of Goods Act, 1979; the levy of entry tax as machinery was not sustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: For entry tax classification, a registered dredger used as a sea-going self-propelled craft is to be treated according to its substantive character as a ship or vessel, and not merely as machinery, where the statutory and common parlance indicators point to vessel classification.

---