Joint venture not taxed as an Association of Persons when one constituent alone bore risk, control, and execution responsibility.

A joint venture formed only to secure a contract was not taxable as an Association of Persons where the supplementary agreement showed that one constituent alone bore the financial risk, executed the project, provided resources, operated the joint bank account, complied with statutory requirements, and remained solely responsible for profits and losses. On those facts, the joint venture agreement was treated as a bidding arrangement rather than a genuine taxable joint activity, and the CBDT circular supported that approach. The contract income was therefore not assessable in the hands of the joint venture, and the addition made on that basis was deleted.

---

---

Issues: Whether the joint venture constituted an Association of Persons liable to tax on the contract receipts, and whether the income from the contract could be assessed in the hands of the joint venture rather than its constituent.

Analysis: The supplementary agreement showed that one constituent alone bore the financial risk, executed the project, provided the resources, operated the joint bank account, complied with statutory requirements, and was solely responsible for profits and losses. The joint venture agreement was held to be only a bidding arrangement entered to secure the contract and not a genuine arrangement creating taxable joint activity for all constituents. The CBDT circular relied upon supported the position that such a consortium, on these facts, was not to be treated as an assessable Association of Persons. On that basis, the income from the contract was not regarded as having accrued in the hands of the joint venture.

Conclusion: The joint venture was not liable to be assessed as an Association of Persons on the contract receipts, and the addition made in its hands was rightly deleted.

Final Conclusion: The Revenue's challenge to the deletion of the estimated income failed, and the assessment could not stand in the hands of the joint venture.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a joint venture is merely a vehicle to secure a contract and, under the governing agreement, one constituent alone bears the risk, control, and responsibility for execution and taxation, the joint venture is not taxable as an Association of Persons on the contract receipts.

---