High Court clarifies treatment of forex gains/losses for ALP under Income Tax Act

The High Court addressed the exclusion of comparables for benchmarking and the treatment of gains/losses from foreign exchange fluctuation in the context of determining the ALP under the Income Tax Act. The Court clarified that forex gain/loss should be treated as operating income/loss, aligning with legal precedents. The appeal was dismissed on certain aspects and admitted for further consideration on the exclusion of comparables issue.

---

---

Issues:
1. Exclusion of comparables for benchmarking
2. Treatment of gains/losses arising from foreign exchange fluctuation in determination of ALP

Issue 1: Exclusion of comparables for benchmarking

The High Court addressed the first issue of excluding certain comparables for benchmarking under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Revenue appealed against the ITAT's order excluding three comparables in one appeal and six comparables in another. The ITAT's reasoning highlighted that forex gain/loss occurs due to exchange rate variations and risk management policies, impacting profit margins. The Court observed that the Safe Harbour Rules were wrongly invoked and held that forex gain/loss should be treated as operating income/loss, aligning with the decision in Woodward Governor's case. Referring to a similar case, the Court concluded that the outgoings related to forex transactions should be considered as operative costs, dismissing the appeal on this aspect.

Issue 2: Treatment of gains/losses from foreign exchange fluctuation

Regarding the treatment of gains/losses arising from foreign exchange fluctuation in the determination of ALP under Section 92CA of the Income Tax Act, the ITAT's decision was analyzed. The Court agreed with the assessee's counsel that forex gain/loss should be considered as operating income/loss due to the nature of the transactions being revenue-based. The Court cited the Woodward Governor's case to support this position. The judgment in a similar case emphasized that the Safe Harbour Rules could not be applied retrospectively, further reinforcing the treatment of forex gain/loss as operational income/loss. The Court found no legal question arising from this issue and admitted the appeal for further proceedings.

In summary, the High Court's judgment addressed the exclusion of comparables for benchmarking and the treatment of gains/losses from foreign exchange fluctuation in the context of determining the ALP under the Income Tax Act. The Court clarified the treatment of forex gain/loss as operating income/loss, citing relevant legal precedents and dismissing the appeal on certain aspects while admitting it for further consideration on the exclusion of comparables issue.

---