Classification of 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' under Tariff Item 0404 90 00 upheld by Tribunal

The Tribunal ruled in favor of the appellant, determining that the 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' should be classified under Tariff Item 0404 90 00. The addition of a small quantity of artificial flavoring substance did not alter the essential nature of the product covered under Heading 0404, and it remained a product consisting of natural milk constituents. The Tribunal referenced previous cases to support this classification, emphasizing that minor additives do not change the fundamental characteristics of milk products. As a result, the appeal was allowed, and the differential Central Excise duty demand and penalty were annulled.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Classification of 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' under the correct Tariff Heading.
2. Legitimacy of the addition of artificial flavouring substances under Tariff Heading 0404.
3. Applicability of previous case laws to the current classification dispute.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Classification of 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' under the correct Tariff Heading:
The primary issue revolves around the classification of the product 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink'. The appellant classified it under Tariff Heading 0404, which attracts a 'nil' rate of duty, while the Revenue sought to reclassify it under Tariff Item 1901 90 90, attracting a 16% rate of duty. The Revenue's argument was based on the addition of Methyl Vanillin Flavour, an artificial flavouring substance, which they claimed disqualified the product from classification under Heading 0404.

2. Legitimacy of the addition of artificial flavouring substances under Tariff Heading 0404:
The appellant argued that the addition of a negligible quantity (0.3%) of artificial flavouring substance should not disqualify the product from being classified under Heading 0404. They contended that Chapter 4 covers dairy products, including those with added vitamins, minerals, and small quantities of stabilizing agents. The adjudicating authority, however, held that the addition of artificial flavouring substances like Methyl Vanillin Flavour would shift the classification to Chapter 19, as it transforms the product into a food preparation.

3. Applicability of previous case laws to the current classification dispute:
The appellant relied on previous case laws, specifically Amrit Foods v. CCE, Meerut and Nestle India Limited v. CCE, New Delhi, to support their classification under Heading 0404. In these cases, the Tribunal ruled that the addition of stabilizers did not alter the essential nature of milk products, and thus, they remained classifiable under Heading 0404. The Commissioner, however, dismissed these precedents, arguing that the artificial flavouring substance in question was not a permitted additive under Heading 0404.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal examined the competing tariff headings and relevant Harmonized System of Nomenclature (HSN) notes. It was concluded that the addition of a small quantity of artificial flavouring substance does not change the essential nature of the product from what is covered under Heading 0404. The Tribunal noted that the HSN notes do not explicitly prohibit flavouring substances in products classified under Chapter 4. Therefore, the product remains a "product consisting of natural milk constituents" and does not become a food preparation that would necessitate classification under Chapter 19.

The Tribunal also referenced the Amrit Foods and Nestle India Limited cases, emphasizing that the addition of stabilizers or minor ingredients does not interfere with the basic characteristics of milk products. Thus, the product 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' should be classified under Tariff Item 0404 90 00.

Judgment:
The Tribunal set aside the impugned order and allowed the appeal, confirming that the correct classification for 'NESCLAC Nutritious Milk Drink' is under Tariff Item 0404 90 00. The differential Central Excise duty demand and the penalty imposed were annulled.

---