Milk-based product classification turns on essential character: stabilizers preserving texture do not shift goods out of dairy heading.

Milk shake mix and soft serve mix were treated as dairy-based preparations made from milk and milk powder with added sugar, glucose and stabilizers. The stabilizers were used only to maintain emulsion, texture, smoothness and shelf life, and did not change the essential dairy character of the goods. Because Chapter Note 4 to Chapter 4 was open-ended and illustrative, the absence of stabilizers from the list did not exclude the products from Heading 04.04. The competing Heading 19.01 was therefore not attracted, and the goods were correctly classified under Heading 04.04.

---

---

Issues: Whether milk shake mix and soft serve mix were classifiable under Chapter Heading 04.04 or under Chapter Heading 19.01 of the Central Excise Tariff.

Analysis: The products were held to be dairy-based preparations made from milk and milk powder with sugar, glucose and stabilizers added. The stabilizers were used only to maintain uniform emulsion, improve texture, smoothness and shelf life, and did not change the basic character of the goods. Chapter Note 4 to Chapter 4 used open-ended and illustrative language, and the absence of stabilizer from the illustrative list did not exclude the products from Heading 04.04. The competing heading under 19.01 was therefore not attracted.

Conclusion: The goods were correctly classified under Chapter Heading 04.04 and not under Chapter Heading 19.01.

Final Conclusion: The Revenue's challenge to the classification failed, and the Tribunal's view was affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi: For tariff classification, the addition of stabilizers that preserve consistency, texture and shelf life does not alter the essential dairy character of a milk-based product where the statutory heading and note are broad and illustrative in nature.

---