Tribunal overturns transfer pricing adjustment, orders fresh determination of Arm's Length Price

The Tribunal set aside the transfer pricing adjustment made by the Assessing Officer based on the Transfer Pricing Officer's order, directing a fresh determination of the Arm's Length Price for the international transaction 'Receipts for services rendered'. Various challenges to the computation of the assessee's Profit Level Indicator were addressed, with adjustments made in the apportionment of costs and selection of comparables. The Tribunal remitted the matter back to the AO/TPO for re-computation of certain aspects, ultimately allowing the appeal for statistical purposes.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Transfer pricing adjustment.
2. Computation of assessee’s Profit Level Indicator (PLI).
3. Inclusion of third-party outsourced service costs as operating costs.
4. Computation of mean Operating Profit/Total Cost (OP/TC) of comparables.
5. Selection of comparables.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Transfer Pricing Adjustment:
The appeal is directed against the transfer pricing adjustment made by the Assessing Officer (AO) based on the order of the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO). The TPO had determined the Arm's Length Price (ALP) for the transaction 'Receipts for services rendered' and made adjustments leading to a transfer pricing addition of Rs. 2,39,11,122/-.

2. Computation of Assessee’s Profit Level Indicator (PLI):
The assessee challenged the computation of its PLI on two counts:
- Apportionment of Unallocable Costs: The assessee allocated the unallocable costs based on headcounts, while the TPO used the ratio of gross revenue. The Tribunal rejected both methods and directed the unallocable costs to be apportioned based on gross profit margins.
- Non-reduction of Sub-contracted Maintenance Services Costs: The assessee argued that Rs. 17,13,222/- spent on third-party maintenance services should be excluded from operating costs as pass-through costs. The Tribunal disagreed, stating that these costs were not separately reimbursed by the AE and thus could not be considered pass-through costs.

3. Inclusion of Third-Party Outsourced Service Costs as Operating Costs:
The Tribunal held that the third-party outsourced service costs amounting to Rs. 17,13,222/- were rightly included in the total operating costs. The argument that these costs should be excluded as pass-through costs was rejected because they were not separately reimbursed by the AE.

4. Computation of Mean OP/TC of Comparables:
The TPO's computation of the mean OP/TC of comparables at 34.95% (later adjusted to 31.35%) was challenged. The Tribunal noted that the TPO did not disclose the manner of calculating the working capital adjustment to the assessee. The Tribunal remitted the matter back to the TPO/AO for re-computation of the working capital adjustment after confronting the assessee with the details.

5. Selection of Comparables:
The assessee contested the inclusion of six companies as comparables:
- Apitco Ltd.: Excluded due to functional dissimilarity and lack of segmental information.
- Best Mulyankan Consultants Ltd.: Retained, but the TPO/AO was directed to recompute its PLI after confronting the assessee.
- Choksi Lab Ltd.: Excluded due to functional differences as it provides testing services, unlike the assessee’s marketing support services.
- Indus Technical and Financial Consultants Ltd.: Retained as no substantial evidence was provided to prove functional dissimilarity.
- RITES Ltd.: Retained, but the TPO/AO was directed to recompute its profit margin from the Consultancy services segment.
- WAPCOS Ltd. (Seg.): Excluded due to functional dissimilarity as it is engaged in infrastructure development projects, unlike the assessee’s marketing support services.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal set aside the impugned order on the issue of transfer pricing adjustment and remitted the matter to the AO/TPO for fresh determination of the ALP of the international transaction 'Receipts for services rendered' in line with the Tribunal’s directions. The appeal was allowed for statistical purposes.

---