Conditional decree for return of ornaments did not trigger interest in execution absent default in returning the property.

A conditional decree directing return of ornaments does not create an immediate money liability or entitle the decree-holder to interest in execution unless the condition triggering payment of the quantified value has first occurred. The decree had to be read as a whole: the obligation was to return the ornaments, and payment of their value arose only on failure to do so. Because no completed default in return was shown and no fixed time for compliance had been set, the obligor could act within a reasonable time. The execution court could not enlarge the decree, and interest was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether interest could be levied in execution on the quantified value of ornaments where the decree directing return of ornaments was conditional and the monetary liability was to arise only on failure to return them.

Analysis: The decree of the Family Court required return of the ornaments and, only on failure to return them, payment of their value. The appellate court did not convert that conditional direction into an unconditional money decree. A judgment must be read as a whole, and the execution court cannot add to or subtract from its terms. Since no specific time was fixed by the appellate court for return of the ornaments, the obligor could comply within a reasonable time. In the absence of a completed default in returning the ornaments, the contingent liability to pay the quantified value and consequential interest did not arise. The earlier proceedings had not finally determined the question of interest in execution, and the High Court misread its own earlier order by treating the interest direction as operative irrespective of non-return of the ornaments.

Conclusion: The direction to pay interest was not sustainable because the monetary liability was contingent upon failure to return the ornaments, which had not been shown to have occurred so as to attract the interest component.

Ratio Decidendi: A conditional decree for return of property does not create an immediate money liability or carry interest in execution unless the condition triggering the monetary obligation has first occurred.

---