Unaided school fee regulation permits transparency-based accounting directions and limited fund transfers within the statutory scheme.

The Supreme Court's reasoning on unaided school fee regulation distinguishes between impermissible diversion of school funds and permitted movement of funds within institutions under the same management if the statutory scheme is respected and a reasonable fee structure is maintained. It also treats requirements to maintain accounts on a not-for-profit basis, prepare balance sheet, profit and loss account, receipt and payment account, and file annual fee statements as valid gap-filling measures. These directions were viewed as consistent with the governing Act and Rules because they promote transparency, accountability, and prevention of profiteering in unaided educational institutions.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the direction prohibiting transfer of funds from the recognised unaided school fund to the society, trust or other institution was inconsistent with Rule 177 of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973. (ii) Whether the additional directions requiring unaided schools to maintain accounts on not-for-profit principles and to file annual fee statements were permissible as ancillary regulatory measures.

Issue (i): Whether the direction prohibiting transfer of funds from the recognised unaided school fund to the society, trust or other institution was inconsistent with Rule 177 of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973.

Analysis: Rule 177 regulates utilisation of fee income by an unaided recognised school and permits savings to be used for specified school-related educational purposes, including assistance to another school or educational institution under the same society or trust. The Court distinguished between appropriation or utilisation of income and outright transfer of school funds to a society or trust. It held that the impugned direction restrained transfers from the school fund, while Rule 177 dealt with permissible application of income for educational purposes, and therefore there was no conflict in principle. At the same time, it clarified that movement of funds between institutions under the same management could not be objected to so long as the arrangement remained within the statutory framework and a reasonable fee structure was maintained.

Conclusion: The prohibition was upheld in substance, but it was clarified that transfer of funds between institutions under the same management is not impermissible.

Issue (ii): Whether the additional directions requiring unaided schools to maintain accounts on not-for-profit principles and to file annual fee statements were permissible as ancillary regulatory measures.

Analysis: The Court held that the regulatory framework under the Act and the Rules did not exhaustively deal with transparency, accounting discipline, surplus determination and appropriation of savings. It treated the additional directions as gap-filling measures intended to ensure accountability, prevent profiteering, and secure a reasonable fee structure. The directions requiring proper accounts, balance sheet, profit and loss account, receipt and payment account, and annual disclosure of fee estimates were viewed as consistent with the object of the statute and the rules, rather than as an impermissible addition to them. The challenge was therefore rejected.

Conclusion: The additional directions were sustained as valid regulatory measures.

Final Conclusion: The review petitions did not succeed, and the earlier decision stood modified only to the limited extent of clarifying that fund transfers between institutions under the same management are permissible within the statutory scheme.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the statutory scheme does not fully address transparency, accounting discipline and surplus utilisation in unaided educational institutions, the Court may uphold regulatory directions that operate as gap-filling measures to prevent profiteering and secure reasonable fee regulation, provided they remain consistent with the governing Act and Rules.

---