Prospective withdrawal of beneficial tax clarification preserves earlier tax benefit and bars retrospective enhancement for prior periods.

A beneficial tax clarification may be withdrawn, but the withdrawal cannot operate retrospectively to deprive the dealer of the benefit already conferred for the earlier period. The Court treated the clarification as an interpretation of the statutory entry and held that, although administrative clarifications do not override the statute, a later clarification altering an existing favourable position applies only prospectively from its date of issue. The impugned clarification was therefore effective only from 11 December 2007, and the earlier 4 per cent treatment continued to govern the prior period.

---

---

Issues: Whether the withdrawal of an earlier tax clarification could operate retrospectively, or whether the subsequent clarification had to apply only prospectively from the date of its issue.

Analysis: The petitioner had obtained an earlier clarification fixing the tax rate at 4 per cent. The later clarification withdrew that view and treated the goods as taxable at 12.5 per cent. The Court held that a clarification issued by the authority is only an interpretation of the statutory entry and may be withdrawn, but where the earlier clarification had conferred a benefit on the dealer, that benefit cannot be taken away for the past period by giving retrospective effect to the later clarification. Administrative clarifications do not override the statute, yet their withdrawal, when it alters an existing beneficial position, operates only from the date of the later clarification.

Conclusion: The impugned clarification was held to be prospective only, effective from 11 December 2007, and not retrospective.

Final Conclusion: The dealer remained entitled to the benefit of the earlier clarification for the prior period, and the enhanced tax position applied only from the date of the later clarification.

Ratio Decidendi: A beneficial tax clarification may be withdrawn, but the withdrawal takes effect prospectively and cannot retrospectively deprive the assessee of the benefit already conferred for the earlier period.

---