Binding tax clarification on star anise seeds requires fresh factual review for earlier assessment years.

A Commissioner's clarification under Section 28-A(3) of the TNGST Act is binding on subordinate authorities, and its effect on earlier assessment years must be examined on the relevant facts. Star anise seeds had been treated variously as a residual item, a country drug, or a First Schedule item, but a later clarification placed them under Item 2 of Part B of the First Schedule. Because the applicability of that clarification to the earlier years required factual determination, the Tribunal's classification could not safely stand. The matter was remitted to the Assessing Authority to decide whether the petitioners could claim the benefit of the clarification and to re-determine the tax rate in accordance with law.

---

---

Issues: Whether the clarification issued by the Commissioner regarding the taxability of star anise seeds should be applied for the relevant earlier assessment years and whether the matter should be remitted to the Assessing Authority for fresh consideration.

Analysis: The commodity in question was variously treated by the authorities as a residual item, a country drug, or an item falling within Part B of the First Schedule. A later clarification issued by the Commissioner under Section 28-A(3) stated that star anise seeds would fall under Item 2 of Part B of the First Schedule. In these circumstances, the earlier classification could not safely be treated as conclusive for the relevant years without examining whether the subsequent clarification should govern those assessments. The Tribunal's classification was therefore not allowed to stand, and the proper course was to leave the applicability of the clarification to the Assessing Authority in the light of the special facts.

Conclusion: The matter was remitted to the Assessing Authority to decide whether the petitioners were entitled to the benefit of the clarification and to determine the rate of tax afresh in accordance with law.

Ratio Decidendi: A clarification issued by the Commissioner under Section 28-A(3) of the TNGST Act is binding on subordinate authorities, and where its applicability to earlier assessment years requires factual consideration, the issue may be remitted for fresh determination.

---