Modvat credit reversal before clearance preserves concessional excise duty eligibility despite fortnightly accounting reversal.

Concessional excise duty under Notification No. 3/2001-C.E. was held available for bulbs with retail sale price not exceeding Rs. 20 where Modvat credit taken on inputs used in intermediate products was reversed before clearance of the final bulbs. The notification required that no credit on inputs or capital goods exclusively used for the notified goods be retained and that duty be paid in cash or through account current. Since the proportionate credit attributable to the bulbs stood deleted in the accounts before removal, the assessee was not treated as having retained that credit. A fortnightly reversal, rather than daily reversal, did not change the legal effect, because no credit benefit remained available at the time of clearance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee was entitled to concessional excise duty under Notification No. 3/2001-C.E. in respect of bulbs of retail sale price not exceeding Rs. 20, where the Modvat credit taken on inputs used in intermediate products was reversed on a fortnightly basis before payment of duty on the final bulbs.

Analysis: The notification granted concessional duty subject to the condition that no credit of duty paid on inputs or capital goods exclusively used in the manufacture of the notified goods had been taken and that duty was paid in cash or through account current. The undisputed position was that the assessee had taken credit on inputs used in intermediate products, but the proportionate credit attributable to the inputs going into the bulbs was reversed before payment of duty on the final goods. The principle applied was that if credit relatable to the exempted or concessional final product stands deleted in the accounts before removal, the assessee cannot be said to have retained the benefit of such credit. The fact that the reversal was made on a fortnightly basis, instead of daily basis, did not alter the legal effect, as the credit stood reversed before clearance of the final product and no benefit of the credit remained available for the impugned bulbs.

Conclusion: The condition of the notification was satisfied, and denial of the concessional rate was not justified.

---