Strict proof of export required for bonded clearances when documents fail to link the goods with the alleged exports.

Goods cleared under bond require strict proof of export and a clear nexus between the bonded clearances and the export documents. The export claim failed because the invoices did not match the consignee and delivery addresses, the bonded bags were used for packing rice rather than exported as empty bags, the shipping bills and bills of lading related to rice in P.P. bags, and customs verification did not corroborate the AR.4s. Overwriting and alteration in the shipping bills further undermined the documents. On these facts, non-compliance with the prescribed export procedure was established and recovery of duty and penalty was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellants established proof of export of the goods cleared under bond so as to avoid recovery of duty and penalty.

Analysis: The proof of export was rejected on several substantive grounds: the invoices did not match the consignee and delivery addresses, the bags cleared under bond were used for packing rice rather than being exported as empty bags, the shipping bills and bills of lading related to rice exported in P.P. bags and not to the empty bags covered by the AR.4s, the export process at the exporter's premises made it impossible to correlate the particular bags with the exported product, verification from customs authorities did not support the link to the AR.4s, and the shipping bills showed overwriting and change of the supporting manufacturer's name. These findings, not being contested, showed non-compliance with the prescribed export procedure and failure to establish a reliable nexus between the bonded clearances and the alleged exports.

Conclusion: The proof of export was not accepted and the demand of duty and penalty was sustainable against the appellants.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods are cleared under bond, the assessee must strictly establish proof of export and a clear correlation between the bonded clearances and the export documents; manipulated or uncorroborated documents defeat such proof and justify recovery of duty and penalty.

---