Just a moment...

⚠✕
❮ Top
☎ Help
☰
×

By creating an account you can:

Logo TaxTMI
Keyword Search :
AI Tools : New
Ask tax questions in natural language. Powered by AI trained on the TaxTMI legal database. Use AI Tools ➞
Call Us / Help / Feedback✕

Contact Us At :

✉ E-mail: [email protected]

✆ Call / WhatsApp at: +91 99117 96707

For more information, Check Contact Us

FAQs :

To know Frequently Asked Questions, Check FAQs

Most Asked Video Tutorials :

For more tutorials, Check Video Tutorials

Submit Feedback/Suggestion :

Email :
Please provide your email address so we can follow up on your feedback.
Category :
Description :
Min 15 characters0/2000
Make Most of Text Search ✕
  1. Checkout this video tutorial: How to search effectively on TaxTMI.
  2. Put words in double quotes for exact word search, eg: "income tax"
  3. Avoid noise words such as : 'and, of, the, a'
  4. Sort by Relevance to get the most relevant document.
  5. Press Enter to add multiple terms/multiple phrases, and then click on Search to Search.
    6. Text Search
  6. The system will try to fetch results that contains ALL your words.
  7. Once you add keywords, you'll see a new 'Search In' filter that makes your results even more precise.
    8. Text Search
╳
Add to...
You have not created any category. Kindly create one to bookmark this item!
✕
Create New Category
Hide
Title :
Description :
❮❮ Hide
❮ Default View
Expand ❯❯
Close ✕
🔎 TMI Notes - Adv. Search ❯
TEXT SEARCH:

Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search

Search In:
Main Text + AI Text ❯
  • Main Text
  • Main Text + AI Text
  • AI Text
Law:
---- All Laws----❯
  • ---- All Laws----
  • Benami Property
  • Bill
  • Central Excise
  • Companies Law
  • Customs
  • DGFT
  • FEMA
  • GST
  • GST - States
  • IBC
  • Income Tax
  • Indian Laws
  • Money Laundering
  • SEBI
  • SEZ
  • Service Tax
  • VAT / Sales Tax
Types:
---- All Types ---- ❯
  • ---- All Types ----
  • Act Rules
  • Case Laws
  • Circulars
  • Manuals
  • News
  • Notifications
Sort By: ?
In Sort By 'Default', exact matches for text search are shown at the top, followed by the remaining results in their regular order.
RelevanceDefaultDate
    NewsBills
    Providing check on survey operations under section 133A of the Act.
    NewsBills
    Provision for e-appeal.
    NewsBills
    Amendment in Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP).
    NewsBills
    Modification of e-assessment scheme.
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT).
    NewsBills
    Rationalization of tax treatment of employer’s contribution to recognized provident funds, superan...
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of section 206C to include TCS on foreign remittance through Liberalised Remittan...
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of TDS on E-commerce transactions through insertion of a new section.
    NewsBills
    Enlarging the scope for tax deduction on interest income under section 194A of the Act.
    NewsBills
    Reducing the rate of TDS on fees for technical services (other than professional services).
    NewsBills
    Allowing deduction for amount disallowed under section 43B, to insurance companies on payment basis.
    NewsBills
    Amendment for providing attribution of profit to Permanent Establishment in Safe Harbour Rules under...
    NewsBills
    Modification of the definition of “business trust”
    NewsBills
    Allowing carry forward of losses or depreciation in certain amalgamations.
    NewsBills
    Deferring TDS or tax payment in respect of income pertaining to Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP) of...
    NewsBills
    Exempting non-resident from filing of Income-tax return in certain conditions.
    NewsBills
    Providing an option to the assessee for not availing deduction under section 35AD.
    NewsBills
    Increase in safe harbour limit of 5 per cent. under section 43CA, 50C and 56 of the Act to 10 per ce...
    NewsBills
    Excluding interest paid or payable to Permanent Establishment of a non-resident Bank for the purpose...
    NewsBills
    Amendment of section 194LD of the Act to extend the period of concessional rate of withholding tax a...
❮
❯
❯❯
MaximizeMaximizeMaximize
0 / 200
Expand Note
Add to Folder

No Folders have been created

    +

    Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?

    NOTE:

    Open Link
    Notes
    Showing Results for :
    Reset Filters
    Results Found:
    Show All SummariesHide All Summaries
    NewsBills
    Providing check on survey operations under section 133A of the Act.
    Show AI Summary
    Survey approval requirements: amended hierarchy now mandates higher-level approval before conducting surveys under section 133A.
    Amendment introduces a tiered prior-approval regime for exercise of survey powers: where information is received from a prescribed authority, lower-ranked officers require prior approval from the intermediate supervisory tier; in other cases, officers below the senior administrative tier require prior approval from that senior tier. The change raises the approval threshold in non-prescribed-authority cases and takes effect from the stated effective date.
    NewsBills
    Provision for e-appeal.
    Show AI Summary
    E-appeal scheme to enable faceless electronic appellate proceedings and permit government to modify appellate procedure.
    A proposed insertion to section 250 empowers the Central Government to notify an e-appeal scheme to enable electronic disposal of appeals, eliminate in-person interface between Commissioner (Appeals) and appellants to the extent technologically feasible, optimise resource use through economies of scale and functional specialisation, and introduce an appellate system with dynamic jurisdiction. The power includes directing, by notification, that statutory provisions on jurisdiction and appellate procedure may not apply or may apply with specified exceptions, modifications and adaptations, and requires such notifications to be laid before both Houses of Parliament.
    NewsBills
    Amendment in Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP).
    Show AI Summary
    Dispute Resolution Panel expansion: added non-resident taxpayers can seek DRP review when AO proposes prejudicial assessment variations.
    Amendment expands the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) procedure to require the Assessing Officer to forward a draft assessment order when proposing any variation prejudicial to the assessee, permitting the taxpayer to file objections with the DRP whose binding directions govern the AO. The definition of eligible assessee is widened to include non-resident persons other than companies alongside foreign companies and cases with transfer pricing adjustments.
    NewsBills
    Modification of e-assessment scheme.
    Show AI Summary
    E-assessment scheme expanded to include best-judgement assessments and extend direction power through a temporary sunset period.
    Amendment expands the E-assessment Scheme, 2019 to include best judgement assessment within the scope of the scheme-making power under sub-section (3A) of section 143, and permits the Central Government to issue directions under the provision for a prescribed limited period, effective from the commencement of the stated assessment year.
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT).
    Show AI Summary
    Commodity Transaction Tax expansion: new tax coverage for options in goods and derivatives tied to other derivatives.
    Amendments expand the scope of Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT) to include sales of derivatives based on prices or indices of commodity derivatives and sales of an option in goods, and replace "recognised association" with "recognised stock exchange". The proposal allocates CTT liability by product and settlement mode-seller liability for derivatives based on derivatives' prices or indices, purchaser liability for exercised options in goods with different treatment for physical delivery versus non-delivery settlement-and updates statutory definitions, the CTT schedule, and value computation accordingly.
    NewsBills
    Rationalization of tax treatment of employer’s contribution to recognized provident funds, superan...
    Show AI Summary
    Employer contribution cap to retirement funds: excess employer contributions taxable and related accretions treated as perquisite.
    A combined upper limit is proposed on employer contributions to the National Pension Scheme, superannuation funds and recognized provident funds; employer contributions exceeding the combined cap in a year will be taxable, and annual accretions to the fund relating to such employer contributions shall be treated as a perquisite to the extent included in total income.
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of section 206C to include TCS on foreign remittance through Liberalised Remittan...
    Show AI Summary
    Tax Collected at Source expanded to cover overseas remittances, tour packages and sales-based collections with specified exemptions.
    Amendments expand Tax Collected at Source (TCS) under section 206C to require authorised dealers to collect TCS on specified overseas remittances under LRS and sellers to collect TCS on sale of overseas tour packages, both with higher rates for non-PAN/Aadhaar cases and specified exemptions. Separately, sellers with turnover above a prescribed threshold must collect TCS on sale of goods above a set consideration limit, subject to notification-based exemptions and exclusions for certain government and diplomatic entities. Provisions take effect from 1 April 2020.
    NewsBills
    Widening the scope of TDS on E-commerce transactions through insertion of a new section.
    Show AI Summary
    TDS on e commerce transactions: operators must withhold on gross platform receipts and treat direct payments as operator credits.
    A new provision imposes TDS on e commerce transactions by requiring the e commerce operator to deduct tax on the gross amount of sales or services when credited to or paid to an e commerce participant; direct payments by purchasers are treated as operator payments. Low volume individual and HUF participants who furnish PAN or Aadhaar are exempt from withholding. The provision overrides other TDS liabilities for the same transactions, excludes operator receipts for unrelated advertising services, and includes definitions and consequential amendments to align withholding and procedural provisions.
    NewsBills
    Enlarging the scope for tax deduction on interest income under section 194A of the Act.
    Show AI Summary
    Tax deduction on interest income: large co-operative societies must withhold tax when turnover and per payee interest exceed specified thresholds.
    The amendment narrows exemptions in section 194A(3) so that a co operative society otherwise exempt under clause (v) or (viia) must deduct tax at source if it exceeds a specified turnover threshold in the preceding year and if the interest credited or paid to a payee in the financial year exceeds specified per payee thresholds, with separate thresholds for senior citizens and others.
    NewsBills
    Reducing the rate of TDS on fees for technical services (other than professional services).
    Show AI Summary
    TDS on technical services adjusted to reduce classification disputes and align withholding with work contract payments.
    To reduce classification disputes and litigation, the law prescribes a reduced withholding rate specifically for fees for technical services (other than professional services), aligning its TDS incidence more closely with that applicable to payments for execution of work contracts; withholding rates for other categories of fees remain unchanged and the amendment takes effect from the commencement date specified in the measure.
    NewsBills
    Allowing deduction for amount disallowed under section 43B, to insurance companies on payment basis.
    Show AI Summary
    Deduction timing for Section 43B: insured business expenses disallowed earlier permitted when actually paid.
    A proviso is proposed to Rule 5 of the First Schedule so that any sum added back under Section 43B in accordance with clause (a) of Rule 5 shall be allowed as a deduction in computing income under the rule in the previous year in which such sum is actually paid; the amendment takes effect from 1 April 2020 and applies to assessment year 2020-21 and onwards.
    NewsBills
    Amendment for providing attribution of profit to Permanent Establishment in Safe Harbour Rules under...
    Show AI Summary
    Attribution to Permanent Establishment now covered in safe harbour rules and advance pricing agreements, providing transfer pricing certainty.
    Amendments expand Safe Harbour Rules to permit acceptance of declared transfer prices that address attribution of profits to a Permanent Establishment, and amend Advance Pricing Agreement provisions to allow APAs to determine or specify the manner of determining such attribution, thereby extending transfer pricing certainty to both safe harbour and APA mechanisms for future and rollback years.
    NewsBills
    Modification of the definition of “business trust”
    Show AI Summary
    Business trust definition modified: listing requirement removed so tax pass-through and regime apply to unlisted trusts.
    The proposal amends clause (13A) of section 2 to remove the requirement that units be listed on a recognised stock exchange for a trust to qualify as a business trust, aligning the income tax definition with SEBI amendments that eliminated mandatory listing for InvITs; under section 115UA such trusts remain subject to taxation rules including pass through treatment for SPV interest and rent and filing and reporting obligations.
    NewsBills
    Allowing carry forward of losses or depreciation in certain amalgamations.
    Show AI Summary
    Carry forward of losses extended to statutory bank and government insurance company amalgamations under specified nationalisation schemes.
    Section 72AA's allowance for carry forward of accumulated losses and unabsorbed depreciation is extended to include amalgamations of corresponding new banks under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Acts and amalgamations of Government companies arising under the General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Act, with defined terms to be read from those enactments and the extension operating notwithstanding specified exclusions in the Act.
    NewsBills
    Deferring TDS or tax payment in respect of income pertaining to Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP) of...
    Show AI Summary
    Deferral of TDS on ESOP perquisites allows employers to delay tax deduction until sale or employment cessation.
    Amendments permit eligible start-ups to defer deduction or payment of tax on ESOP perquisites: tax must be deducted or paid within fourteen days of the earliest of (i) expiry of the prescribed post-allotment period, (ii) sale of the specified security or sweat equity share by the employee, or (iii) cessation of employment. Tax is computed using the rates applicable in the financial year when the security or share was allotted or transferred.
    NewsBills
    Exempting non-resident from filing of Income-tax return in certain conditions.
    Show AI Summary
    Non-resident return filing exemption extended to royalty and FTS when withholding tax is applied at prescribed rates.
    A statutory amendment will exempt a non-resident from filing an income-tax return where the non-resident's total income consists solely of dividend or interest, or specified royalty or fees for technical services, provided that withholding tax on such income has been deducted under Chapter XVII-B at rates not lower than the rates prescribed for tax determination under section 115A(1); the amendment takes effect from the stated commencement date and applies to the relevant assessment year and subsequent years.
    NewsBills
    Providing an option to the assessee for not availing deduction under section 35AD.
    Show AI Summary
    Optional 35AD deduction safeguards right to claim depreciation where assessee forgoes the investment allowance under amended rules.
    The amendment makes the 100% capital expenditure deduction under section 35AD optional and restricts the sub section (4) non allowance rule so that other deductions, including normal depreciation, are disallowed only if the section 35AD deduction has been claimed and allowed; the change applies prospectively to the assessment year beginning 1 April 2020.
    NewsBills
    Increase in safe harbour limit of 5 per cent. under section 43CA, 50C and 56 of the Act to 10 per ce...
    Show AI Summary
    Safe harbour threshold for stamp valuation adjustments increased, reducing valuation-driven recharacterisation of consideration for transfers.
    Increase of the safe harbour threshold from five per cent to ten per cent for valuation comparisons where declared consideration for transfer or receipt of immovable property is lower than the stamp valuation authority's value, so that a declared consideration within the safe harbour is treated as the full value for computing capital gains or income from other sources; effective from 1st April, 2021 and applying to the relevant assessment year and subsequent years.
    NewsBills
    Excluding interest paid or payable to Permanent Establishment of a non-resident Bank for the purpose...
    Show AI Summary
    Interest limitation carve-out excludes debt from permanent establishments of foreign banks from interest disallowance under amended rules.
    The amendment provides that the interest limitation will not apply to interest paid in respect of debt issued by a lender which is a permanent establishment of a non-resident engaged in banking in India, thereby carving out loans from branches of foreign banks from the section 94B restriction and avoiding application of the earnings based disallowance to such debt.
    NewsBills
    Amendment of section 194LD of the Act to extend the period of concessional rate of withholding tax a...
    Show AI Summary
    Concessional withholding tax extended and applied to municipal debt, enabling foreign investor interest relief within a renewed operative window.
    Amendment to section 194LD extends the concessional withholding tax regime and applies the concessional rate to interest on municipal debt securities by Foreign Institutional Investors and Qualified Foreign Investors, preserving the reduced TDS rate for eligible interest payments and changing the operative period so that interest paid within the newly prescribed window qualifies for the concession, with the amendment taking effect from the start of the specified fiscal period.

    TMI Notes

    Back

    All TMI Notes

    Showing Results for :
    Reset Filters
      No Records Found

      TMI Notes

      Home› TMI Notes › Indian Laws › Case-Laws › Category › This
      Back

      All TMI Notes

      whatsappJoin Channel
      Showing Results for : Reset Filters
      Indian Laws

      Ensuring Fair Procedure before declaring Fraud in Bank Loan: Providing Relevant Documents and Opportunity to be Heard

      10 August, 2024

      Contents
      Acts
      Plus +
      Summary
      Note

      Note

      -

      Bookmark

      Print

      Print

      Print Options

      Deciphering Legal Judgments: A Comprehensive Analysis of Case Law

      Reported as:

      2024 (5) TMI 1323 - DELHI HIGH COURT

      Introduction

      The judgement under analysis pertains to a writ petition filed by an ex-director and guarantor of a company (hereinafter referred to as "the Petitioner") against various banks (hereinafter referred to as "the Respondents"). The Petitioner challenged the Show Cause Notices (SCNs) issued by the Respondents for declaring the account of the company as 'Fraud'. The crux of the matter revolved around the alleged non-compliance with the agreed terms of the loan documents and various irregularities in the loan account, leading to suspicion of fraudulent activities.

      Arguments Presented

      Petitioner's Arguments

      The Petitioner contended that the SCNs were issued without providing the requisite documents, which formed the basis of the allegations. The Petitioner argued that the absence of such documents rendered it impossible to submit a proper reply to the SCNs. The Petitioner highlighted the following key points:

      Respondents' Arguments

      The Respondents contended that the requisite documents had already been provided to the Petitioner. The lead bank, State Bank of India (SBI), submitted that it was ready to grant an inspection of the company's records available with it. Additionally, the Respondents argued that:

      • No final decision had been taken by the banks, and only SCNs had been issued at this stage.
      • The judgments relied upon by the Petitioner were not applicable to the present case, and they did not provide for granting a personal hearing to the Petitioner.
      • The Respondents relied on the Supreme Court's order in Rajesh Agarwal's case to contend that granting a personal hearing by the banks was not mandatory.

      Discussions and Findings of the Court

      The Court discussed the settled principles of law regarding the applicability of the Principles of Natural Justice and the requirement to provide relevant documents forming the basis of a SCN. The Court relied on the Supreme Court judgments in Kanwar Natwar Singh & Kanwar Jagat Singh Versus Directorate of Enforcement - 2010 (10) TMI 156 - Supreme Court and T. Takano v. Securities and Exchange Board of India to emphasize the importance of disclosing relevant materials to enable an effective reply.

      The Court also referred to the Supreme Court's decision in State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal, which held that the classification of an account as 'Fraud' under the Reserve Bank of India's Master Directions on Frauds leads to a credit freeze for the borrower. Consequently, the Principles of Natural Justice must be followed, and the borrower should be given an opportunity to be heard before classifying the account as fraud.

      Analysis and Decision by the Court

      The Court acknowledged that fair procedure and the Principles of Natural Justice require the provision of requisite documents forming the basis of a SCN to enable the concerned party to submit a proper reply. Failure to provide relevant documents would render the entire procedure of issuing a SCN and filing a reply an empty formality.

      The Court emphasized that the relevant documents forming the basis of the SCN must be provided to the concerned party to enable them to raise an effective defense. Denying this fundamental right by not providing the requisite documents would violate the Principles of Natural Justice.

      Considering the submissions made by the lead bank (SBI) and the Petitioner's counsel regarding the availability of the company's records with the RP, the Court issued the following directions:

      1. The Petitioner and/or his authorized representative shall be allowed to inspect the records of the company available with SBI (the lead bank).
      2. The Petitioner and/or his authorized representative shall also be allowed to inspect the records of the company available with the RP.
      3. Upon inspection, the Petitioner shall state the specific documents required from the company's records that form the basis of the SCNs. These documents shall be provided to the Petitioner.
      4. The cost of providing copies of the relevant documents shall be borne by the Petitioner.
      5. The process of inspection, stating the specific documents, and providing the relevant documents shall be completed within specified timelines.
      6. Upon receipt of the documents, the Petitioner shall file a reply to the respective SCNs within a specified timeline.
      7. The Petitioner is at liberty to request a personal hearing from the respective banks, which shall be considered accordingly.

      The Court disposed of the writ petition in terms of the aforesaid directions.

      Doctrine or Principle Discussed

      The primary doctrine discussed in the judgement is the Principles of Natural Justice, specifically the principle of audi alteram partem (hear the other side). The Court emphasized the importance of providing relevant documents and an opportunity to be heard before taking an adverse decision against a party.

      Comprehensive Summary

      The judgement dealt with a writ petition challenging Show Cause Notices (SCNs) issued by various banks for declaring the account of a company as 'Fraud'. The primary issue was the alleged non-compliance with the agreed terms of the loan documents and various irregularities in the loan account, leading to suspicion of fraudulent activities.

      The Petitioner, an ex-director and guarantor of the company, argued that the SCNs were issued without providing the requisite documents forming the basis of the allegations. The Petitioner contended that the absence of such documents rendered it impossible to submit a proper reply, violating the Principles of Natural Justice.

      The Court discussed the settled principles of law regarding the applicability of the Principles of Natural Justice and the requirement to provide relevant documents forming the basis of a SCN. The Court relied on various Supreme Court judgments, including T. Takano v. Securities and Exchange Board of India and State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal, to emphasize the importance of disclosing relevant materials and providing an opportunity to be heard before taking an adverse decision.

      The Court acknowledged that fair procedure and the Principles of Natural Justice require the provision of requisite documents forming the basis of a SCN to enable the concerned party to submit a proper reply. Failure to provide relevant documents would render the entire procedure an empty formality.

      Considering the submissions made by the lead bank (SBI) and the Petitioner's counsel regarding the availability of the company's records with the Resolution Professional (RP), the Court issued directions for the Petitioner and/or his authorized representative to inspect the records of the company available with SBI and the RP. The Petitioner was directed to state the specific documents required from the company's records that formed the basis of the SCNs, and these documents were to be provided to the Petitioner within specified timelines.

      The Court also directed that upon receipt of the documents, the Petitioner shall file a reply to the respective SCNs within a specified timeline. Additionally, the Petitioner was granted the liberty to request a personal hearing from the respective banks, which shall be considered accordingly.

      The Court disposed of the writ petition in terms of the aforesaid directions, upholding the Principles of Natural Justice and the right to access relevant documents and be heard before an adverse decision is taken.

       

       

      Full Text:

      2024 (5) TMI 1323 - DELHI HIGH COURT

      Topics

      ActsIncome Tax
      Next ➔