TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2014 (8) TMI 859
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.....2 In the appeals before the Tribunal, the assessee had called in question the order dated 18.12.2010 passed by the Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Admn.) (for short the 'revisional authority') in exercise of the powers under Section 63-A of the KVAT Act. The revisional authority reversed the assessment orders dated 11.12.2006 passed under Section 38(1) of the KVAT Act, for the tax period commencing from April 2005 upto March 2006, by the Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit-9), LDU Division, Bangalore (for short the 'assessing authority'). 2. Briefly stated the facts leading to these revision petitions are as under: 2.1 The assessee in these revision petitions is a Company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and also a registered dealer under the provisions of the KVAT Act. The assessee is engaged in the manufacture and sale of various kinds of paints, varnishes, thinners etc., including road marking paints/material. The road marking paints/material, hereinafter shall be referred to as 'RMP'. The assessing authority, had passed the assessment orders, dated 1.1.12.2006, accepting the return of turnover file....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....; 3. Whether the appellant proves that Assessing Authority as well as First Appellate Authority erred in treating freight charges paid and reflected in profit and loss account of appellant as part of taxable turnover and further erred in levying tax on the same? 4. Whether the appellant proves that AA as well as FAA erred in disallowing the exemption on sales returns? 5. Whether the appellant proves that AA and FAA erred in levying full tax on inter-state sales without giving sufficient opportunity to the appellant to submit -'C' forms?" 2.4 All the questions were answered by the Tribunal in favour of the assessee and against the department. Insofar as the first question is concerned the Tribunal held that though RMP is a composite mixture of Aliphatic petroleum Hydrocarbon resin, Titanium dioxide, glass beads, Calcium carbonate and Additives, since dominant ingredient contained is petroleum resin it (RMP) will have to be classified as petroleum resin. Having so observed, the Tribunal held that the RMP sold by the assessee is entitle....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....deal with the first question which was addressed by both the learned counsel at length. Mrs. S.Sujatha, learned AGA appearing for the Department submitted that RMP, which is known in the trade as 'Apcomark' and Thermoline', is an unclassified item exigible to tax at 12.5% in terms of Section 4(l)(b) of the KVAT Act and not at 4% as declared by the assessee in its monthly returns filed in Form VAT 100. She submitted that RMP being a finished product cannot be catagorised as petroleum resin. After inviting our attention to Entry No.51 of the 3rd Schedule of the KVAT Act, which deals with 'industrial inputs and taking materials as may be notified', she submitted that - RMP cannot be classified as petroleum resin as specified at SI.No.133 or 139 of the Notification No.FD 197 CSL 2005(6) Bangalore dated 30.04.2005 (SI.No.22) (for short 'the Notification'). In short, she submitted that road marking material is not covered by the Notification and hence exigible to tax at the rate of 12.5% as contemplated by Section 4(l)(b)(iii) of the KVAT Act. 5.1 She further submitted that the test to be applied for classification for the purpose of excise duty is the comm....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....C 558. 6. On the other hand, Mr. Shivadass, learned counsel appearing for the assessee submitted that the RMP is classified under Chapter 39 and assigned HSN code 3911.90.90 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (for short CET Act') by virtue of the application of the General Rules for interpretation of the First Schedule to the CET Act (for short 'Rules for Interpretation'). He submitted that the Rules for interpretation, in particular Rule 3(b) thereof, would give the RMP, being a mixture of different components/chemicals,(petroleum resin being a dominant component), its essential character to the RMP-mixture. After inviting our attention to HSN code 3911 and entries at SI.No.139 of the Notification namely sub-headings 3911.10.10 and 3911.10.90, he submitted that once the road marking material is classified under chapter heading 3911 as petroleum resins it gets covered under SI.No.133 and/or SI.No.139 of the Notification. 6.1 He then submitted that SI.No.51 of the third Schedule refers to the industrial inputs and packing materials that should be notified. The notification notifies industrial inputs and packing materials which are liable to be taxed at the rate....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... differ from paint. He submitted that though the mixture is a physical blend of Aliphatic Petroleum Hydrocarbon Resin, Titanium Di Oxide, Calcium Carbonate, Glass Beads and Additives, the petroleum resin present in the mixture provide essential character to the product-RMP. 6.5 In support of his contentions, he placed reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Kemrock Industries & Exports Ltd v. CCE 2007 (210) ELT 497 (SC), Collector of Central Excise v. Wood Polymers Ltd. 1998 (97) ELT 193 (SC), Collector of Central Excise v. Bakelite Hylam Ltd. 1997 (91) ELT 13 (SC) and Jyothy Laboratories Ltd. v. State of Assam [2011] 46 VST 308 (Gauhati). In support, he also invited our attention to the report of the National Test House, Government of India, dated 11-11-2009. 7. For dealing with the first question of law, we need to examine whether the product-RMP of the assessee-company, which is known as 'Apcomark' and Thermoline' can be classified as petroleum resin and that it is covered by the entries at SI.No.133 or 139 of the Notification. In other words, it will have to be examined whether the existence of petroleum resin namely Aliphatic Petroleum Hydrocarbon ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... 139 139 3911.10.10 3911.10.90 Coumarone-indene resins Other petroleum resins 10. It would be relevant to reproduce the tariff item No.3911 along with description of goods, unit, and rate of duty in Chapter 39 of the CET Act, which reads thus: Tariff Item Description of goods Unit Rate of duty 3911 Petroleum resins, Coumarone-indene resins, Polyterpenes, Polysulphides, Polysulphones and other products specified in Note 3 to this Chapter not elsewhere specified or included, in primary forms 3911 10 Petroleum resins, coumarone indene or coumarone-indene resins and polyterpenes: 3911 10 10 Coumarone-indene resins kg. 16% 3911 10 90 Other kg. 16% 3911 90 Other 3911 90 10 Polysulphones kg. 16% 3911 90 90 Other kg. 16% 11. To understand and interpret the relevant entries/serial numbers, headings and sub-headings, description of goods in the Notification better it would be relevant to look into the explanations appended to the Notification, which reads thus: "Explanations- (1) the Rules ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....iption in the CET Act then only those commodities described in Column 3 of the Notification will be covered by the scope of Notification and other commodities though covered by the corresponding description in the Central Excise Tariff will not be covered by the scope of this Notification. 14. There doesn't appear to be any dispute that the assessee described their product by assigning HSN code 3911.90.90. This HSN Code, however, does not find place in the entries at SI.No.133 and 139 in the Notification. SI.No. 133 in the Notification provides HSN Code with heading and sub-headings bearing 3911, 3911.10.10 and 3911.10.90. The sub-heading 3911.90.90 does not find place in the Notification. It was, therefore, submitted, that petroleum resin, used in the RMP is not covered by SI.No.133 heading 3911 or SI.No.139 sub-heading 3911.10.10 or 3911.10.90. It was further submitted that if the legislature intended to cover all sub-headings under tariff 3911 in Chapter 39 of the CST Act, it would not have given specific sub-headings at SI.No.139 in the Notification. In other words, the legislature would have incorporated only Entry at SI.No. 133 with heading 3911 in the Notification. ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
...., provided such headings or Notes do not otherwise require, according to the following provisions. 2 (a) ................. (b) Any reference in a heading to a material or substance shall be taken to include a reference to mixtures or combinations of that material or substance with other materials or substances. Any reference to goods of a given material or substance shall be taken to include a reference to goods consisting wholly or' partly of such material or substance. The classification of goods consisting wholly or partly of such material or substance. The classification of goods consisting of more than one material or substance shall be according to the principles of rule 3. 3. When by application of rule 2(b) or for any other reason, goods are, prima facie, classifiable under two or more headings, classification shall be effected as follows: (a) the heading which provides the most specific description shall be preferred to headings providing a more general description. Howev....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....it was found that these samples are physical blends of following Chemicals and not dispersed product like that of liquid paint. (a) Aliphatic Petroleum Hydrocarbon resin Chemical provides bonding to concrete or tar road surface when applied as a hot melt using a special machine. (b) Titanium dioxide (TI02) white Pigment Chemical-used to improve brightness of the marking which in turn improve safety on road due or better visibility. (c) Calcium Carbonate (CAC03) Chemical-used as filler to give thickness file reinforcement and control flow. (d) Glass Beads retro reflective properties to improve night visibility on the road. (e) Additivies to ensure properties such as flaw index, hardness etc. The % constituents of the above stated raw materials of APCOMARK/THERMOLINE samples are shown in the T.C.No.NTH(ER)/CH(P)/2008-148A, B & C respectively. The road marking material tested above is a simple physical blend of above chemicals since all the chemicals are possible to be isolated individually and there is an observable chemical change in the identity or composition. Being the Physical blend of several chemicals, road marking materials cannot be applied as such li....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....n question is a composite goods, the test of essentiality will have to be. applied to find out whether petroleum resin being one of the ingredients/component gives its essential character to the product (RMP). 21. Chapter 39 of CET Act deals with 'plastic and articles thereof. As stated above, under heading 3911 petroleum resins, Coumarone-indene resins, polyterpenes, polysulphides, polysulphones and other products specified in Note 3 to this Chapter, not elsewhere specified or included, in primary forms stand covered as plastics and other articles thereof. It is not in dispute that the product in question (RMP) is a composite item. Since the product in question is a composite goods, the test of essentiality shall apply. The test of essentiality refers to "essential character". The test states that, if the manufactured goods has the essential character of petroleum resins, then one has to treat the product as petroleum resins. 22. Rule 3(b) of the Rules for interpretation requires that composite goods, mixtures and goods put up in sets have to be classified on the classification of that material or component which gives to the product their essential character. In other w....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ependent properties/characteristics, which plays its role to call it RMP. Insofar as Aliphatic Petroleum Hydrocarbon resin, which is a petroleum resins, is concerned it provides bonding to concrete or tar road surface when applied as hot melt using a special machine. At the time of application of hot melt road marking powder is heated gradually up to 180-200 C under continuous agitation in a pre-melting equipment. The Aliphatic Petroleum Hydrocarbon Resin melts and thereby Titanium Dioxide white Pigment chemical, Calcium Carbonate chemical, Additives and glass beads are homogenized by stirring to form fluid paste. The paste then is transferred to an application equipment where the material is maintained in a molten state under continuous agitation. The homogenized molten material is passed through the narrow slit in the application equipment opening to cast marking on the road. It is thus clear that these materials/components are dry solid blend (physical mixture) of several chemicals which are heated, melted and homogenized and then cast on the road with specialized equipment. When we look at the properties/characteristics of each of the chemical we find that Aliphatic Petroleum H....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....sp; "The mere fact that the substance or raw material out of which it is made has also been taxed in some other form, when it was sold as a separate commercial commodity, would make no difference for purposes of the law of sales tax. The object appears to us to be to tax sales of goods of each variety and not the sale of the substance out of which they are made..... As soon as separate commercial commodities emerge or come into existence, they become separately taxable goods or entities for purposes of sales tax..... The law of sales tax is also concerned with 'goods' of various Descriptions. It, therefore, becomes necessary to determine when they cease to be goods of one taxable description and become those of a commercially different category and description." 25.2 In M.P. Agencies v. State of Kerala [2010] 28 VST 44 (Kar.). The Karnataka High Court after noticing the observations made by the Supreme Court in Sterling Foods v. State of Karnataka [1986] 63 STC 239 observed that when the product made from industrial raw material or commercial commodity with distinct use and purpose, it cannot be treated as raw material from which it is made. 26....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....puter for the purpose of mixing of various colours as per the desired requirements of the customers. UPS. which is known as convertor, is used for continuous supply of electricity so that the dispensation process in the tinting machine is not affected. The tinting machine is usable only in combination with computer and UPS. The question is when they are sold together whether it should be treated as one single unit. There is no dispute that without computer and UPS, tinting-colour world machine cannot be used for the purpose of intermixing paints. As per the brochure provided by the Company, colour world machine constitute an equipment comprising of tinting machine, computer and UPS. It is not in dispute that the assessee-Company give the colour world machines on rent, consisting of all the three units and the lease rental is paid to the assessee by the lesseses as one unit. 27.2 Thus, we find ourselves in agreement with the findings recorded by the assessing authority, that the tinting machine, computer and UPS, when are sold as one single unit, should be taxed as unclassified attempt under Section 4(1)(b) of the KVAT Act. The finding of fact recorded by the Tribunal that all th....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....On the face of it the question as framed is not a question of law and it does not arise for our consideration. There is sufficient material on record, as referred to by the Tribunal, to sustain the findings of fact that the freight charges were received along with the price of goods and/or that the assessee paid freight charges and that they never recovered from the buying dealers/distributors. The third question stands answered accordingly. 29. The last question of law pertains to disallowance of assessee's claim towards "sales returns". The assessee has produced adequate documents and detail / statement on record which reveal invoice numbers, date / and when the goods were received in their premises. In order to demonstrate the methodology adopted, they have also placed on record VAT-100 Form filed in the month of November 2008, during which, sales returns were shown of Rs. 1,28,65,773/-. They have also placed on record lorry receipts regarding the return of goods mentioning invoice numbers along with dates in support of their case of sales returns. Sales returns are also filed on record for the relevant period which show the movement of goods including lorry receipt numbe....