Reassessment and fee-for-technical-services classification: reopening upheld, but certain reimbursements and mobilization charges fell outside treaty ...
Section 80P deduction for co-operative societies remains available despite nominal members and housing society status, with limited interest income tr...
An order granting valuation and the first opportunity to purchase shares was treated as self-operative: once the fair value reports were available, the appellant had to accept the valuation and indicate willingness to buy, without any further formal offer. By rejecting the higher valuation and seeking averaging of the reports, the appellant failed to exercise the first option, so the respondents' right to purchase the shares at the accepted fair value crystallised. The Tribunal also held that a later challenge to the valuation and a belated offer to buy could not revive a waived right after the arrangement had been acted upon. The appeal was dismissed and the sale in favour of the respondents was sustained.
An order granting valuation and the first opportunity to purchase shares was treated as self-operative: once the fair value reports were available, the appellant had to accept the valuation and indicate willingness to buy, without any further formal offer. By rejecting the higher valuation and seeking averaging of the reports, the appellant failed to exercise the first option, so the respondents' right to purchase the shares at the accepted fair value crystallised. The Tribunal also held that a later challenge to the valuation and a belated offer to buy could not revive a waived right after the arrangement had been acted upon. The appeal was dismissed and the sale in favour of the respondents was sustained.
Note: It is a system-generated summary and is for quick reference only.
TaxTMI 
of 4803
Join Channel
TaxTMI 
