Transfer pricing requires evidence for AMP transactions, functionally reliable comparables, and appropriate aggregation or Berry Ratio benchmarking me...
Revisionary jurisdiction cannot reopen share capital assessments where adequate inquiry supports a permissible view and no independent error is establ...
Reassessment jurisdiction fails where unverified portal information is aggregated without examining the taxpayer's explanation or relevance of entries...
Statutory sanction for delayed reassessment requires approval from the prescribed authority; approval by an inferior authority invalidates jurisdictio...
Transfer pricing margin adjustments require matching treatment of non-operating income and related costs, with comparability issues reconsidered on ev...
Preliminary-expense amortisation and MAT exempt-income adjustments prevailed, while trademark costs and managerial remuneration require fresh verifica...
Export valuation requires contemporaneous evidence; unrelated invoices cannot prove overvaluation, and dual penalties on firm and partner are impermis...
The applicant entered into an agreement with the Central Hospital, South Eastern Railway to provide catering services by running the in-house kitchen, for which the hospital is liable to pay consideration. The issue pertains to whether the supply of food to inpatients by the applicant is exempt from GST as a composite supply of healthcare services or is taxable as a standalone supply of food. The authority held that the applicant is supplying services to the hospital, which provides healthcare services to patients. The supply of food by the applicant to the hospital is a standalone service and cannot be considered a composite supply of healthcare services. GST is payable on the service of supplying food, and no exemption is provided as the service is outsourced by the hospital, and the applicant is not a clinical establishment. The authority relied on the Telangana AAR ruling, which held that GST is payable on outsourced food supply services by hospitals.
The applicant entered into an agreement with the Central Hospital, South Eastern Railway to provide catering services by running the in-house kitchen, for which the hospital is liable to pay consideration. The issue pertains to whether the supply of food to inpatients by the applicant is exempt from GST as a composite supply of healthcare services or is taxable as a standalone supply of food. The authority held that the applicant is supplying services to the hospital, which provides healthcare services to patients. The supply of food by the applicant to the hospital is a standalone service and cannot be considered a composite supply of healthcare services. GST is payable on the service of supplying food, and no exemption is provided as the service is outsourced by the hospital, and the applicant is not a clinical establishment. The authority relied on the Telangana AAR ruling, which held that GST is payable on outsourced food supply services by hospitals.
Note: It is a system-generated summary and is for quick reference only.
TaxTMI 
of 4801
Join Channel
TaxTMI 
