Supply of Tangible Goods - appellant had provided the excavators...

Supply of Tangible Goods - appellant had provided the excavators & JCB machines without transferring right of possession & effective control - The tribunal found that the transactions in question, covered by both long-term and short-term charter agreements regarding tankers, qualified as a transfer of the right to use goods with possession and effective control being transferred to the lessee, thereby falling outside the scope of service tax liability. Consequently, the demand for service tax, along with interest and penalties imposed, set aside.