Transfer pricing comparables and adjustments: Tribunal revisits loss-maker status, segmental comparability, working capital relief, and risk allocatio...
Business expenditure disallowance failed where commission, related-party salary and promotion payments were supported by records and inquiry was inade...
Management support services supported by agreements, invoices, allocation records, presentations, e-mails and time sheets were treated as genuine business services, not mere stewardship or shareholder activities, so the arm's length price could not be fixed at nil without applying a recognised transfer pricing method. In the manufacturing segment, TNMM analysis showed the tested party's operating margin remained higher than the corrected comparable margin, so no transfer pricing adjustment could survive. The appellate deletion of both adjustments was sustained.
Management support services supported by agreements, invoices, allocation records, presentations, e-mails and time sheets were treated as genuine business services, not mere stewardship or shareholder activities, so the arm's length price could not be fixed at nil without applying a recognised transfer pricing method. In the manufacturing segment, TNMM analysis showed the tested party's operating margin remained higher than the corrected comparable margin, so no transfer pricing adjustment could survive. The appellate deletion of both adjustments was sustained.
Note: It is a system-generated summary and is for quick reference only.
TaxTMI 
of 4805
Join Channel
TaxTMI 
