Manpower supply

[yateen vyas]

Sir,

If we made a contract with contractor for any work and we will not mention anywhere manday supply.Like for any work if i will give monthly contract even work is done by labour but my contract was only for wrok that has to be done.Does it will fall under manpower supply please take this issue with all rules & regulation.

Rgds

Yateen vyas

[Siva Sankaran]

If the work is done alone with manpower then it will attract service tax within the scope of Supply of Manpower. If the service provided is combined with materials and labour then it will be taxed under Works Contract.

[Mahaganapathi V]

Dear Sir

This issue is a wider one and cannot be answered in tow lines. I would advise you to take the provisions of ESI and PF Acts where in even a contractor's  labours are considered as indirect employees and the necessary provisions are applicable accordingly. In India there are many Acts which enforces tax for a single transaction. For Ex:- a works contract has two portions of activity 1. supply or materials 2. supply of service. The first aspect is covered under VAT and the second is covered under Service Tax. There are different methods to pay the tax in these laws. The issue does not stop here. As i have mentioned in the beginning the ESI, PF comes and plays a role for the indirect employment. There are judgements from the Apex court which says " to decide whether a contractor's labour is the indirect employee of the contractee or the employee of the contractor one should analyse the terms of the contract". Even for a single day of employment these contributions to be made which makes the small and medium business technically in to confusions and the fact is there are huge amount standing unclaimed at the governments account.. Further the point to be asked here is if PF and ESI was paid on a labour contract transaction, how again service tax can be enforced? This country has lot of authorities where by the business people are getting more notices. At times such Notices are even more in number than their business orders...:-)

AI Summary

Clarification on Service Tax: Manpower Supply vs. Works Contract, Consider ESI, PF Acts, and Dual Taxation Issues A forum participant raised a query about whether a contract for work, without specifying manpower supply, falls under the category of manpower supply for service tax purposes. One respondent clarified that if the work involves manpower alone, it attracts service tax under manpower supply, but if combined with materials, it is taxed as a Works Contract. Another respondent highlighted the complexity of the issue, advising consideration of ESI and PF Acts, and pointing out the dual taxation under VAT and Service Tax for works contracts. They also discussed the confusion caused by overlapping regulations and the burden of compliance on businesses.