Need advice on Taxation on Silver ETF FOF

[Faizan Uddin]

I am in new tax regime and have CTC of 8LPA. I have invested in Silver ETF for. If I sale my investment in less than 2 years, then will my tax on gains would be 20% special rate of STCG or would it be applicable at income tax slab rate. Since my CTC is less than 12 lacs, then selling in less than 2 years would help me save on tax.

[Ryan Vaz]

Short Practical Answer

You are partially correct: you will save tax, but only if you sell within 12 months (not 2 years).

1. If sold < 12 Months: The gain is Short Term Capital Gain (STCG). It is added to your salary and taxed at your Slab Rate (approx. 10% for your income level). This is the cheapest option for you.

2. If sold > 12 Months (but < 2 years): The gain is Long Term Capital Gain (LTCG). It is taxed at a flat 12.5%. You cannot choose the slab rate for this; the flat rate is mandatory.

The "20% special rate" you mentioned applies to Equity Shares (Section 111A). Silver ETFs are non-equity, so that rate does not apply.

AI Summary

Silver ETF capital gains: slab-rate STCG vs 12.5% LTCG u/s 112 for new tax regime investors An investor under the new tax regime with an annual package of approximately ?8 lakh sought clarification on capital gains tax for a Silver ETF fund-of-fund when sold within two years. The response explains that tax treatment depends on holding period: if units are sold within 12 months, gains are treated as short-term capital gains and taxed at the investor's applicable slab rate, which is likely lower than special rates and thus more tax-efficient. If units are sold after 12 months but before two years, gains become long-term and are taxed at a mandatory flat 12.5%. The 20% concessional rate applies to specified equity instruments, not Silver ETFs.