Exemption notification for named hand tools cannot be denied for lack of end-use proof where no such condition is stated.

CEGAT held that an exemption notification naming specific hand tools under Chapter 82 could not be read as requiring proof of actual agricultural or horticultural end-use where no such condition was stated for those named goods. The words referring to tools of a kind used in agriculture or horticulture were treated as extending only to unspecified tools, not as qualifying the goods expressly described in the notification. Because the respondents' goods fell within the named description, exemption could not be denied on the ground that the tools might also be usable in other industries. The Revenue's objection failed and the exemption was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the respondents were entitled to exemption under Notification No. 111/88 for hand tools falling under Chapter 82 without proof of actual agricultural or horticultural end-use.

Analysis: The notification granted exemption to the goods specifically described by name in the table, and also to other tools of a kind used in agriculture or horticulture. The expression relating to agriculture or horticulture was held to extend the scope only to unspecified tools, and not to impose an actual end-use requirement on the goods expressly named in the notification. Once the respondents' goods fell within the named description and under Chapter 82, the benefit could not be denied merely because they might also be usable in other industries. The absence of an end-use stipulation in the notification was decisive.

Conclusion: The exemption was admissible to the respondents, and the Revenue's objection based on absence of end-use proof failed.

Final Conclusion: The order granting exemption was upheld and the Revenue's appeal was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an exemption notification expressly names goods and separately refers to other goods of a kind used in a specified field, the specified end-use condition cannot be read as a requirement for the goods named expressly in the notification unless the notification so states.

---