Natural justice in valuation appeals requires disclosure of relied-upon documents and a reasoned order before fresh adjudication.

An appellate order that set aside a valuation enhancement without reasons, and without supplying the valuation report and other relied-upon documents, was treated as non-speaking and contrary to natural justice. Because the importers had not been given an effective opportunity to reply to the materials relied on by the department, the matter required fresh consideration. The appellate authority was directed to reconsider all pleas, furnish the relied-upon documents, and pass a reasoned order after giving adequate opportunity of hearing. The result was remand for fresh adjudication in observance of natural justice.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellate order setting aside the valuation enhancement without reasons, and without supplying the materials relied upon by the department, required remand for fresh consideration.

Analysis: The impugned order was found to be non-speaking, as it set aside the adjudication order without assigning reasons. It was also noticed that the importers had not been given the valuation report and other relied upon documents, resulting in a failure of natural justice. In these circumstances, the matter was required to be sent back so that the appellate authority could consider all pleas, furnish the relied upon documents, and pass a reasoned order after giving adequate opportunity of reply.

Conclusion: The matter was remanded to the appellate authority for fresh decision after observance of natural justice and for passing a speaking order.

Ratio Decidendi: A non-speaking appellate order passed without furnishing relied upon material and without affording an effective opportunity of reply cannot stand and warrants remand for fresh adjudication.

---