Fresh classification list not required absent tariff or heading change under Central Excise Rules, and the departmental appeal failed.

Rule 173B(4)(c) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 requires a fresh classification list, or amendment to an existing list, only where there is a change in duty rate arising from an amendment to the tariff, or a change in chapter heading or sub-heading. On the facts noted, none of those contingencies had occurred, so the department had no basis to insist on a fresh classification list. The notice under appeal was confined to the filing of a classification list and did not support the broader demand advanced by the department. A fresh classification list was therefore not required, and the departmental appeal failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether a fresh classification list was required to be filed under Rule 173B(4)(c) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 in the absence of any change in the tariff, chapter heading, or sub-heading.

Analysis: Rule 173B(4)(c) permits filing of a fresh classification list or amendment to an existing list only when there is a change in the rate of duty by reason of an amendment to the tariff, or a change in the chapter heading or sub-heading. On the facts found, none of those contingencies had occurred. The notice under appeal was also confined to the filing of a classification list and did not justify the demand for a fresh list on the footing urged by the department.

Conclusion: A fresh classification list was not required, and the departmental appeal failed.

---