Synthetic textile material controls exemption eligibility for blended yarn, not the narrower staple fibre description.

Yarn of artificial staple fibre containing non-cellulosic synthetic waste was treated as containing synthetic textile material for purposes of Sl. No. 14(a) of Notification No. 53/91-C.E. The notification used broader language than synthetic staple fibre, and Section Note 2(D) of Section XI of the Central Excise Tariff Act distinguished textile material from fibre material. On that basis, the yarn did not satisfy the exemption condition and fell under the higher rate in Sl. No. 14(b). The later explanation inserted on 1-3-1992 was relied on as clarificatory of the same position.

---

---

Issues: Whether yarn of artificial staple fibre containing non-cellulosic synthetic waste qualifies for the concessional rate under Sl. No. 14(a) of Notification No. 53/91-C.E. as yarn not containing any synthetic textile material.

Analysis: The relevant entry in the notification excluded yarn containing any synthetic textile material, not merely synthetic staple fibre. Section Note 2(D) of Section XI of the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 defines the expressions synthetic, artificial and man-made in relation to textile materials as well as fibres, and makes the distinction between textile material and fibre material clear. Non-cellulosic synthetic waste was treated as synthetic textile material for the purpose of the notification, and the fact that waste is not the same as synthetic staple fibre did not assist the assessees because the notification used broader language. The later explanation inserted on 1-3-1992 was relied upon as clarificatory of the same position.

Conclusion: The yarn containing non-cellulosic synthetic waste did not satisfy the condition in Sl. No. 14(a) of Notification No. 53/91-C.E. and was liable to the higher rate under Sl. No. 14(b). The Revenue's appeal succeeded and the assessees' appeals failed.

Final Conclusion: The governing distinction was between synthetic staple fibre and synthetic textile material, and the latter expression controlled eligibility for the exemption.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an exemption entry excludes goods containing any synthetic textile material, the condition is not met by showing only that the blended waste is not synthetic staple fibre; the broader statutory meaning of synthetic textile material under the tariff prevails.

---