Tariff classification of medicated products drove the pre-deposit waiver dispute, with partial stay granted after prima facie examination.

Tariff classification of Clohex and Stolin was the central issue in considering waiver of pre-deposit. The applicant claimed classification as patent or proprietary medicines under Heading 30.03, while the department treated the products as preparations for oral or dental hygiene under Heading 33.06. The order noted the products' composition, possible pharmacopeial use, the absence of clear packing indications for cosmetic or toilet use in Clohex, and the need for closer examination of the second product. On that basis, full waiver was declined, a partial deposit was ordered, and recovery of the balance duty demand was stayed upon compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the applicant had made out a prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit in respect of the duty demand on the products Clohex and Stolin, and whether the demand warranted full stay pending appeal.

Analysis: The dispute turned on the proper tariff classification of the products, with one side asserting classification under Heading 30.03 as patent or proprietary medicines and the other contending that they fell under Heading 33.06 as preparations for oral or dental hygiene. The order notes the product composition, references to pharmacopeial use, the absence of clear packing indications for cosmetic or toilet use in respect of Clohex, and the need for deeper examination for the second product. The main demand was also substantially referable to the first product.

Outcome: Full waiver was not granted. The applicant was directed to deposit Rs. 2 lakhs within one month, and on such deposit, recovery of the balance duty demand was stayed.

---