Chapter 39 classification for polypropylene tapes and sacks confirmed; Board instructions were binding on departmental officers.

Polypropylene tapes and sacks were treated as classifiable under Chapter 39 because the classification list was read broadly to cover products made from HDPE and polypropylene, and the disputed goods fell within that description. Board instructions issued under Section 37B, based on the Chief Chemist's advice, directed similar polypropylene tapes and sacks to Chapter 39, and departmental officers were bound to follow those instructions. An artificial factual distinction between the goods was rejected, reinforcing the binding force of Board circulars on field formations under the principle in Ranadey Micronutrients.

---

---

Issues: Whether polypropylene tapes and sacks were to be classified under Chapter 39 in accordance with the Board's instructions issued under Section 37B, and whether the field formation was bound to follow those instructions.

Analysis: The classification list covered products made from both HDPE and polypropylene, and the description was sufficiently clear to include the disputed polypropylene tapes and sacks. The Board had issued clear instructions, based on the Chief Chemist's advice, directing classification of similar polypropylene tapes and sacks under Chapter 39 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. The attempt to distinguish the goods on the basis of an artificial factual difference was rejected. The binding force of Board instructions on field formations was reinforced by the principle stated in Ranadey Micronutrients.

Conclusion: The classification was to be made under Chapter 39, and the Board's instructions were binding on the departmental officers; the assessee's appeal succeeded.

---