Modvat credit on furnace refractories treated as admissible before the 16-3-1995 amendment under input and capital goods rules

Refractories used as furnace lining material were considered eligible for Modvat credit for the period before 16-3-1995. The analysis applied earlier decisions treating parts and spares of items covered by the exclusion clause as outside that exclusion, and treated the 16-3-1995 amendment as clarificatory. On that reasoning, the refractories were regarded as modvatable either as inputs under Rule 57A or as capital goods under Rule 57Q, with eligibility extending to the pre-amendment period.

---

---

Issues: Whether refractories used as lining material for the furnace were eligible for Modvat credit prior to 16-3-1995, either as inputs under Rule 57A or as capital goods under Rule 57Q.

Analysis: Refractories were found to be lining materials for the furnace. The earlier decisions relied upon had treated parts and spares of items mentioned in the exclusion clause as not covered by that exclusion and therefore eligible as inputs under Rule 57A. The amendment effective from 16-3-1995 was treated in prior decisions as clarificatory, and the same approach was applied here. On that basis, the refractories were held to be modvatable even for the period before 16-3-1995.

Conclusion: Modvat credit on refractories was admissible even prior to 16-3-1995, and the appeal was allowed.

---