Tariff classification disputes may be remanded on appeal when reconsideration of goods classification is needed in light of precedent.

Tariff classification of HDPE/PP strips, tapes and fabrics was treated as a mixed question of law and fact, so it could be examined at the appellate stage and reconsidered through remand. The Collector (Appeals) was held not to have exceeded jurisdiction by sending the matter back for fresh classification in light of relevant precedent, and no infirmity was found in that course. The departmental challenge therefore failed, the remand order was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Collector (Appeals) exceeded jurisdiction in remanding the matter for fresh classification of HDPE/PP strips, tapes and fabrics.

Analysis: The dispute concerned the proper tariff classification of the goods, and the remand was made so that the classification issue could be reconsidered in light of relevant precedent. Classification of goods was treated as a mixed question of law and fact, capable of being raised and examined even at the appellate stage. On that basis, no infirmity was found in the remand order.

Conclusion: The remand was upheld and the departmental challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was dismissed, leaving the remand order intact.

Ratio Decidendi: Classification disputes are mixed questions of law and fact and may be examined at the appellate stage, including by way of remand.

---