Tariff classification of moulded vehicle seats turns on the more specific entry and the tariff period in force.

Specially moulded latex foam sponge seats made for scooters, auto-rickshaws, tractors and jeeps were classified by reference to the more specific tariff entry applicable to their functional character and the relevant period of the tariff. For the period before 1-3-1982, they were treated as parts and accessories of motor vehicles under Tariff Item 34-A because their identity and use were confined to particular vehicles. After the amendment to Tariff Item 16-A(1), which expressly covered articles made of latex foam sponge, that entry became the specific classification for the later period. The result was different for the two periods, reflecting the governing tariff language in force at each time.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether moulded seats for scooters, auto-rickshaws, tractors and jeeps were classifiable, for the period prior to 1-3-1982, under Tariff Item 34-A as parts and accessories of motor vehicles or under Tariff Item 16-A(1) as latex foam sponge; and (ii) whether, for the period after 1-3-1982, the amended Tariff Item 16-A(1) covering articles made of latex foam sponge displaced classification under Tariff Item 34-A.

Issue (i): Whether moulded seats for scooters, auto-rickshaws, tractors and jeeps were classifiable, for the period prior to 1-3-1982, under Tariff Item 34-A as parts and accessories of motor vehicles or under Tariff Item 16-A(1) as latex foam sponge.

Analysis: The seats were manufactured as specially moulded latex foam sponge products for use only in particular vehicles. Their functional identity was as vehicle parts, and their use was confined to the intended motor vehicles. In that setting, the more specific entry for the relevant period was the one covering parts and accessories of motor vehicles.

Conclusion: For the period prior to 1-3-1982, classification under Tariff Item 34-A was correct and the view of the Tribunal was erroneous.

Issue (ii): Whether, for the period after 1-3-1982, the amended Tariff Item 16-A(1) covering articles made of latex foam sponge displaced classification under Tariff Item 34-A.

Analysis: The amendment introduced articles made of latex foam sponge within Tariff Item 16-A(1). Once that entry expressly covered the moulded seats, it became the more specific classification for the later period.

Conclusion: For the period after 1-3-1982, classification under the amended Tariff Item 16-A(1) was correct and the Tribunal's view was upheld.

Final Conclusion: The dispute was resolved differently for the two periods, with the assessee succeeding for the pre-amendment period and the Revenue succeeding for the post-amendment period.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods are specially moulded for a particular functional use, tariff classification depends on the more specific entry applicable to their character and the governing period of the tariff, including any later amendment expressly covering the goods.

---