Tariff classification of slitter-cum-rewinder machines as paper cutting machines defeats confiscation and penalty.

Tariff classification of a slitter-cum-rewinder machine was determined by the explanatory notes to Heading 84.33 of the CCCN and Heading 84.41 of the HSN, which expressly include slitter-reelers and slitter-winders used to unwind, slit, and rewind paper reels. On that basis, the machine answered the description of a paper cutting machine in international tariff parlance. The text states that, consequently, confiscation was unsustainable and penalties were set aside in favour of the assessee because the goods were not to be treated as differently classifiable.

---

---

Issues: Whether a slitter-cum-rewinder machine is covered as a paper cutting machine and therefore not liable to confiscation and penalty.

Analysis: The relevant classification was determined by reference to the explanatory notes to Heading 84.33 of the CCCN and Heading 84.41 of the HSN. Those notes expressly include slitter-reelers and slitter-winders used for unwinding reels of paper, slitting them into required widths, and rewinding them. On that basis, the imported machine answered the description of a paper cutting machine in international tariff parlance.

Conclusion: The machine was held to be a paper cutting machine, the confiscation was unsustainable, and the penalties were set aside in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the tariff nomenclature and explanatory notes expressly include slitter-rewinder type machines within paper cutting machines, such machines cannot be treated as differently classifiable goods for the purpose of confiscation or penalty.

---