Imported car valuation: manufacturer's price catalogue accepted where invoice and later certificate were found unreliable.

Imported car valuation was upheld on the basis of the manufacturer's price catalogue because the appellant's invoice did not reflect the true market value, having shown only a special diplomatic price not generally available. A later certificate was rejected as unreliable since it did not match the car's description, date, or engine details. In the absence of a genuine invoice, the manufacturer's catalogue supplied to authorised local agents was accepted as a proper basis for assessment under Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Rule 3A of the Valuation Rules.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessable value of the imported car was correctly determined on the basis of the manufacturer's price catalogue and whether the appellant's invoice and subsequent certificate could be accepted as the basis of valuation.

Analysis: The invoice produced by the appellant was found not to represent the true and real value, as it reflected a special diplomatic price not available generally. The certificate obtained later was held to be unreliable because it did not correlate with the imported car's description and the date and engine details did not match. In the absence of a genuine invoice, the price catalogue issued by the manufacturer to its authorised local agents was accepted as a proper basis for valuation, consistent with valuation under Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Rule 3A of the Valuation Rules.

Conclusion: The assessable value was validly determined on the basis of the manufacturer's price catalogue, and the appellant's challenge to the valuation failed.

---