Modvat credit on titanium anodes was upheld where the goods were used in manufacture and not covered by machinery exclusions.

Titanium anodes used in caustic soda manufacture were treated as eligible for Modvat credit because they were actually used in the manufacturing process and the Modvat scheme covered goods used in relation to manufacture. The exclusion for machines, machinery, plant, equipment, apparatus, tools or appliances was held not to extend automatically to their parts, so the objection that titanium anodes were merely machinery parts was rejected. Earlier decisions and the wider scope of the Modvat scheme supported this view, and entitlement to credit on the anodes was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether Titanium Anodes used in the manufacture of caustic soda were eligible for Modvat credit and whether they were excluded as machinery parts.

Analysis: The Tribunal noted that earlier decisions had consistently held Titanium Anodes or similar anodes to be eligible for credit in the manufacture of caustic soda, and that the Supreme Court had upheld the Tribunal's view under the narrower Notification No. 201/79-C.E. The Tribunal further held that the Modvat scheme was wider in scope, covering goods used in relation to manufacture, and that the exclusion for machines, machinery, plant, equipment, apparatus, tools or appliances did not extend to their parts. Titanium Anodes were found to be actually used in the manufacture and not to fall within the excluded category of machinery itself.

Conclusion: The Titanium Anodes were eligible for Modvat credit and the objection that they were merely machinery parts was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was dismissed and the assessee's entitlement to Modvat benefit on Titanium Anodes stood upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods actually used in the manufacture of final products are eligible for Modvat credit unless they are themselves among the specifically excluded categories, and the exclusion of machinery does not automatically extend to machinery parts.

---