Trade parlance test limits paper exemption: base paper's printability alone does not make it printing and writing paper.

Exemption under Notification No. 55/86-Cus. depended on whether the goods answered the common or trade parlance description of "printing and writing paper" within the relevant tariff headings. Mere capability of being printed or written upon was not enough; the paper had to be recognised as printing and writing paper by substance and commercial identity. The HSN Explanatory Notes to Heading 48.02 were treated as persuasive in distinguishing base paper for conversion from paper used for writing, printing or other graphic purposes. On that approach, "Document Raw Base Paper" was treated as base paper and not eligible for the concession claimed.

---

---

Issues: Whether "Document Raw Base Paper" qualified as "printing and writing paper" for exemption under Notification No. 55/86-Cus. as amended, and whether the goods were entitled to concessional customs duty thereunder.

Analysis: The exemption applied only to paper falling within the specified headings and answering the description of "printing and writing paper" of the prescribed substance by weight. The paper's mere capability of being printed or written upon was held insufficient. The relevant test was whether the goods were known in common or trade parlance as printing and writing paper. The Explanatory Notes to Heading 48.02 of the HSN were treated as having persuasive value in distinguishing base paper used for conversion from paper of a kind used for writing, printing or other graphic purposes. On that basis, "Document Raw Base Paper" was treated as falling in the category of base paper rather than printing and writing paper.

Conclusion: "Document Raw Base Paper" was not eligible for exemption under Notification No. 55/86-Cus. as amended.

Final Conclusion: The substantive view taken was against exemption for the disputed goods, but the matter was referred for constitution of a larger Bench because an earlier Tribunal decision had taken a different view.

Ratio Decidendi: For exemption notifications, the description of goods must be satisfied in common or trade parlance, and mere capability of use for printing or writing does not make base paper "printing and writing paper".

---