Tariff classification turns on design, use and chapter notes; filing cabinets and tool cupboards fall under furniture classification.

Classification under the Central Excise Tariff depends on the wording of the heading read with the relevant chapter and section notes, together with the article's design and intended use. Filing cabinets designed for floor placement were treated as furniture under Heading 94.03 rather than office equipment under Heading 83.04, with noscitur a sociis supporting that reading. Tool boxes constructed as front-opening cupboards with shelves and a hanging rod were also treated as furniture under Heading 94.03, and were excluded from Chapter 73 by the section note excluding Chapter 94 articles. The discussion confirms that specific exclusions and the functional nature of the goods prevail over a broader competing classification.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether filing cabinets were classifiable under Heading 83.04 or under Heading 94.03 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. (ii) Whether tool boxes were classifiable under Heading 73.26 or under Heading 94.03 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Issue (i): Whether filing cabinets were classifiable under Heading 83.04 or under Heading 94.03 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Analysis: Heading 83.04 covers filing cabinets only as office or desk equipment of base metal other than office furniture of Heading 94.03. Chapter Note 2 to Chapter 94 requires furniture of Heading 94.03 to be designed for placement on the ground or floor. The product catalogue showed that the filing cabinets were designed to be placed on the ground, and the heading had to be read as a whole with the accompanying items in the same genus. Applying the principle of noscitur a sociis, the expression was read in the context of office or desk equipment and not furniture of Heading 94.03.

Conclusion: The filing cabinets were rightly classified under Heading 94.03 and not under Heading 83.04.

Issue (ii): Whether tool boxes were classifiable under Heading 73.26 or under Heading 94.03 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Analysis: The technical drawing showed a front-opening metal cupboard with shelves, hanging rod and a base for floor placement, rather than a box with a lid. On its construction and use, the article was in the nature of furniture. HSN Explanatory Notes supported classification of cupboards used for tools under Heading 94.03, and once so treated, the goods stood excluded from Chapter 73 by Section Note 1(k) to Section XV because articles of Chapter 94 are outside that Section.

Conclusion: The tool boxes were rightly classified under Heading 94.03 and not under Heading 73.26.

Final Conclusion: The classification adopted by the lower authorities was sustained for both products, and the appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Classification under the Central Excise Tariff must be determined by the wording of the heading read as a whole, the relevant chapter and section notes, and the article's design and intended use; a specific exclusion within a heading and the nature of the goods as furniture will prevail over a claimed more general classification.

---