1990 (12) TMI 240 - AT - Central Excise

Classification of Sanitary Napkins under Central Excise Tariff Act upheld, exemption claim rejected

The court upheld the classification of sanitary napkins under Heading 4818.00 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, rejecting the appellant's claim for ... Classification Issues:Classification of sanitary napkins under Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 - Heading 6201.00 vs. Heading 4818.00Detailed Analysis:1. Background: The appeal challenges the order classifying sanitary napkins under sub-heading 4818.00 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals), Bombay. The appellants claimed exemption under Heading 6201.00 but were directed by the Department to classify the goods under Heading 56.01.2. Appellant's Argument: The appellants argued that sanitary napkins fall under Heading 6201.00 as they are articles for wearing by women, made of wood pulp wadding covered in non-woven fabric with outer coverings of viscose fiber or blended fabrics. They contended that Chapter 48 is ruled out due to the product's composition.3. Respondent's Argument: The Respondent referred to the Assistant Collector's detailed reasoning, emphasizing the composition and functional character of the product. They highlighted that Heading 4818.00 includes articles of cellulose wadding, which is predominant in sanitary napkins, giving them their essential character. They argued against the applicability of Chapter 62 to the goods.4. Classification Analysis: The judgment analyzed the composition of sanitary napkins, noting the wood pulp absorbent mass, non-woven fabric covers, and polyethylene film. The cellulose wadding in the product imparts its essential character as an absorbent pad for women during menstruation. Rule 3 of the Excise Tariff interpretation rules was applied, leading to the classification under Heading 4818.00.5. Tariff Alignment: The judgment highlighted the alignment between the Central Excise and Customs Tariffs based on the Harmonised Commodity Description and Coding System (HSN). It emphasized that Heading 4818.00 covers sanitary articles made of cellulose wadding, aligning with the product's nature and purpose.6. Conclusion: The judgment agreed that sanitary napkins do not qualify as articles of apparel under Chapter 62 due to their hygienic purpose and one-time use. The product's classification under Heading 4818.00 was deemed correct, considering its composition and functional character. The appeal was rejected, affirming the lower authorities' classification decision.This detailed analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the issues involved in the classification of sanitary napkins under the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, emphasizing the composition, purpose, and relevant tariff headings governing the classification decision.