Forging classification prevails over residuary duty heading when imported rotor forgings retain their commercial identity.

Rough machined rotor forgings were held to retain the commercial identity of forgings for countervailing duty classification. Although the goods had the profile and essential character of the finished component, they were still not usable as turbine components in imported form. The specific forging entry under Item 26AA was therefore preferred over the general residuary description of goods not elsewhere specified, because classification must follow the goods' true commercial identity and a specific heading prevails over a residuary one. The assessment was confined to the forging entry, giving relief on the duty classification issue.

---

---

Issues: Whether rough machined rotor forgings were classifiable for countervailing duty under Item 26AA as forgings rather than under a general residuary description of goods not elsewhere specified.

Analysis: The description in the bill of entry identified the goods as rough machined rotor forgings. The goods had the profile and essential character of the finished component, but as imported they were still forgings and not usable as turbine components. For the limited choice relevant to countervailing duty, classification under the forging entry was held to be more appropriate than treating them as goods not elsewhere specified. The conclusion also followed the principle that a more apt specific heading should prevail over a general or residuary one when the goods are described by their true commercial identity.

Conclusion: The goods were correctly assessable under Item 26AA, and not under the residuary description, for countervailing duty; the appeal succeeded on this point.

Final Conclusion: The assessment was confined to the forging entry, resulting in relief to the assessee on the duty classification issue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where imported goods retain the commercial identity of forgings, classification must be made under the specific forging entry rather than a general residuary head, even if the goods have the profile or essential character of the finished article.

---