Taxable service classification: re-rubberising client-owned printing rollers falls under Business Auxiliary Service rather than repair service.

Re-rubberisation of old and used printing rollers, involving removal of worn-out rubber, application of fresh rubber compound, vulcanisation and grinding, is described as processing of client-owned goods and therefore falling within Business Auxiliary Service. Although the activity may also be viewed as reconditioning under Management, Maintenance or Repair Service, neither competing taxable-service entry is more specific or provides a distinct essential character. The applicable classification rule consequently places the activity under the entry occurring first, Business Auxiliary Service, rather than Management, Maintenance or Repair Service.

---

---

Issues: Whether re-rubberisation of old and used printing rollers is classifiable as Business Auxiliary Service or as Management, Maintenance or Repair Service.

Analysis: The activity involved removal of worn-out rubber, application of fresh rubber compound, vulcanisation and grinding of the rollers. It constituted processing of goods received from clients and was consequently covered by Business Auxiliary Service. Although reconditioning could also fall within Management, Maintenance or Repair Service, the activity was prima facie classifiable under both categories. Applying the classification rule for competing taxable-service entries, neither service was more specific nor did either furnish an essential character distinct from the other; classification therefore followed the entry occurring first, namely Business Auxiliary Service under section 65(105)(zzb), before Management, Maintenance or Repair Service under section 65(105)(zzr).

Conclusion: Re-rubberisation of the printing rollers is classifiable as Business Auxiliary Service and not as Management, Maintenance or Repair Service; the finding is in favour of the assessee.

---