Operating income under TNMM includes normal export forex gains, while valid CSR-linked donations may still qualify for section 80G deduction.

Foreign exchange gains from realisation of export proceeds for IT/ITES services are treated as operating income for TNMM where they arise in the normal course of business, and their exclusion from operating results is not justified on first principles or by inapplicable safe harbour rules. A donation forming part of CSR expenditure remains eligible for deduction under section 80G if it is supported by a valid 80G certificate and no applicable statutory bar applies. Foreign tax credit claims under section 90 may be restored for verification before credit is granted. Interest under sections 234A, 234B and 234C and initiation of penalty under section 270A follow the assessment as consequential matters.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether foreign exchange gains arising on realisation of export proceeds from provision of IT/ITES services were to be treated as operating in nature while computing arm's length price under TNMM; (ii) whether deduction under section 80G could be denied in respect of donation forming part of CSR expenditure paid to Odisha State Disaster Management Authority; (iii) whether denial of foreign tax credit under section 90 required restoration for verification; and (iv) whether interest under sections 234A, 234B and 234C and initiation of penalty under section 270A survived.

Issue (i): whether foreign exchange gains arising on realisation of export proceeds from provision of IT/ITES services were to be treated as operating in nature while computing arm's length price under TNMM.

Analysis: The foreign exchange fluctuation gains arose from normal business realisation of export proceeds for services rendered in the ordinary course of business. Safe harbour provisions were not applicable as the assessee had not opted for them, and the operating nature of such gains was examined on first principles and prior precedent. The adjustment in the ITES segment depended on inclusion of such gains in operating income.

Conclusion: The foreign exchange gains were held to be operating in nature, and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (ii): whether deduction under section 80G could be denied in respect of donation forming part of CSR expenditure paid to Odisha State Disaster Management Authority.

Analysis: The payment was treated by the lower authorities as CSR expenditure under section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013, but the authority to claim deduction under section 80G was examined separately from the disallowance under section 37(1). The donation was supported by a valid 80G certificate, and the statutory bar relied upon by the Revenue was not applicable to the donation in question.

Conclusion: The deduction under section 80G was directed to be allowed in accordance with law, and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (iii): whether denial of foreign tax credit under section 90 required restoration for verification.

Analysis: The parties were agreed that the claim had to be verified by the Assessing Officer before credit could be granted, as the credit had not been given while computing the tax demand despite no adverse finding on entitlement.

Conclusion: The matter was restored to the Assessing Officer for verification and grant of relief in accordance with law.

Issue (iv): whether interest under sections 234A, 234B and 234C and initiation of penalty under section 270A survived.

Analysis: These consequences followed the assessment and did not require separate adjudication in the appeal on merits.

Conclusion: The challenge to interest and penalty initiation was not accepted.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded on the core transfer pricing and section 80G issues, the foreign tax credit claim was remitted for verification, and the remaining consequential grounds were rejected or not interfered with.

Ratio Decidendi: Foreign exchange gains from realisation of normal export proceeds in the course of business are operating income for TNMM, and a CSR-linked donation otherwise eligible under section 80G is not disallowed merely because it forms part of CSR expenditure.

---