Photograph printing as manufacture: transforming soft-copy images into photo books falls outside service tax on photography services.

Printing photographs from soft copy onto paper and binding them into photo books was treated as manufacture because the process materially changed the identity and nature of the input into a distinct commercial product. On that basis, the activity fell within the printed matter classification under Chapter 4911 and was covered by the relevant service tax exemption notifications. The contrary view advanced by the Revenue was rejected in light of earlier precedent. Service tax on photography services was therefore not leviable, and the demand with consequential penalty was set aside in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the activity of printing and developing photographs in a colour lab amounts to manufacture and is outside the levy of service tax on photography services.

Analysis: The appellant was engaged in printing photographs from soft copy onto paper and binding them as photo books. The activity was treated as involving a change in identity and nature of the goods, resulting in a distinct commercial product. The reasoning followed earlier authority holding that such printing activity is manufacture, and that the activity falls within the printed matter classification under Chapter 4911. The decision also noted that printing activity had been exempted by the relevant service tax notifications and that the contrary view relied upon by the Revenue was not accepted in light of the affirmed earlier precedent.

Conclusion: The activity amounted to manufacture and was not taxable as photography service. The demand of service tax and consequential penalty were set aside, in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where printing of photographs materially transforms the input into a distinct commercial product, the activity is manufacture and not a taxable photography service under the service tax levy.

---